https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_women%27s_nati...
The former seems reasonably plausible, if the trends you mention hold true.
- Iceland (population 350,000 or so) reached the quarter finals of the European championships, a tournament with, probably, stronger teams in the finals than the world championships. Only 13 teams from Europe can qualify for the latter. Looking at the world rankings, all of those are in the top 20 of the world, and, for example, Serbia, at 23 wouldn’t make it to the final 32.
- South Korea ended fourth at the world’s, mostly by wanting it more.
I don’t see why the USA wouldn’t be able to better than those, certainly if they get a bit of luck on their side.
Remember, Greece won Euro 2004 but have struggled since, often not even qualifying. Greece are not a good team. Period. By the same token, just because the Netherlands failed to qualify once or because Germany were knocked out in the first round of a world cup, that does not make either a weak team - they just had an off-day.
All said, i agree with the original point - i won't be surprised if the USA men's football team is a force to reckon with in the next decade. Same goes for the Canadian men's team.
The Greek team from today and from 2004 do not share a single member, do they?
Of course, you could argue that some institutional factors persist?
That’s reflected in the fact that, currently, 8 of the top 10 countries are from Europe (the other two are the usual suspects Brazil and Argentina)
One difference is that, unlike in chess, there still are many uneven matches. If you’re Liechtenstein, Andorra, or Gibraltar, for example, you’ll play lots of qualifiers against Spain, France, Germany, and the like (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UEFA_Nations_League corrects that a bit, giving such teams much better chances to tie or even win games). You don’t see such things in chess.
It wouldn’t surprise me if the USA men’s team would become world champion within a few decades. The sport is growing rapidly in Spanish-speaking areas, Spanish-speakers are the fastest growing linguistic group in the United States, the country is sport-minded, and the USA men’s team already is ranked 11th in the world (https://www.fifa.com/fifa-world-ranking/men?dateId=id13505) (ahead of Germany!)