News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by vorpalhex on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @04:12PM (#29655279)
Nobody cares that you teach the history of racism in the US, correctly educate children about the civil war and slavery or talk about civil rights heroes.

What most people object to are the Derrick Bell arguments that racial segregation is good, that racism is fundamental and unsolvable and that equality is not achievable or real. These are illiberal views that have no place being taught.

Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by kennywinker on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @04:35PM (#29655646)
If you’re trying to describe critical race theory, that’s not it.
Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by vorpalhex on Thursday December 23, 2021 @01:31AM (#29659246)
Derrick Bell is one of the original CRT scholars. He believes desegregation was a mistake. [1]

CRT holds, as a critical tradition, that there are fundamental unsolvable struggles. In critical gender theory this struggle is on the basis of gender, and in CRT this struggle is on the basis of race. The struggle can not be resolved, only inverted.

I have read the work of Bell and Delgado, well liked overviews supported by CRT proponents and quite a few essays on the matter.

I would recommend reading the source material and not the version of it touted in the press. Delgado in particular has many.. interesting views.

[1] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derrick_Bell

Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by kennywinker on Thursday December 23, 2021 @02:01AM (#29659413)
I don't think we have the time, nor is this the place to discuss CRT in detail. But nothing in your citation (wikipedia) says that he believed that the goal of desegregating society is a mistake, or as you put it "racial segregation is good", only that school desegregation might have had so much blowback that it did more harm to black communities than good. Which is not an "illiberal" idea.
Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by vorpalhex on Thursday December 23, 2021 @11:51AM (#29663620)
> Bell concluded, therefore, that the focus for American educational systems should not be on national integration but, rather, should be on improving the quality of education provided for black students.

More depth is given here,

> "From the standpoint of education, we would have been better served had the court in Brown rejected the petitioners' arguments to overrule Plessy v. Ferguson," Bell said, referring to the 1896 Supreme Court ruling that enforced a "separate but equal" standard for blacks and whites. While acknowledging the deep injustices done to black children in segregated schools, Bell argued the court should have determined to enforce the generally ignored "equal" part of the "separate but equal" doctrine.

Via https://news.stanford.edu/news/2004/april21/brownbell-421.ht...

If you don't want the lights on, you are in fact asking for the lights to be turned off. There is no third option. You may prefer the answer to be stated in a given way - and this is a game that CRT proponents play - but logically the conclusion is the same. If you don't support desegregation, you are in favor of segregation.

I know a different group of people who are pro-segregation, believe racism is a fundamental non-resolvable struggle and think we should be keeping the races separated: that is literally the alt-right platform.

Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by kennywinker on Thursday December 23, 2021 @03:24PM (#29666056)
I'm sorry but that's not sound logic.

> If you don't support desegregation, you are in favor of segregation.

If I don't support vapes as a tool for quitting smoking, that doesn't mean I support smoking. There's more than two options. Nicotine gum, patches, hypnotherapy, cold turkey, etc.

You're getting caught up in the idea that not supporting "forcibly de-segregating school in the 1960s" is the same as supporting racial separation. "Desegregation" in this context isn't the idea of racial separation, it's a specific event where schools were racially unified over a period of a few years - but also probably caused a significant blowback (white flight) that some believe did more harm to black communities than good.

It's not hard to imagine a scenario where from 1967 to 1977 the schools remained segregated, but black schools were funded as well or better than white schools (emphasizing the equal in "separate but equal"), at which point they were desegregated - but not forcibly and abruptly. The desegregation happened organically over the next 10-20 years. Would we be better off? Have more racial harmony, or less? Would we have prevented white flight, or just delayed it? I don't think exploring these possibilities is racist, illiberal, segregationist, or unproductive. Especially as we search for solutions to the racism that is apparent in america today (unsolvable? maybe... I hope not).

Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by vorpalhex on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:00PM (#29666416)
What is the third choice between segregation and desegregation? Bell does not propose any kind of half-segregation or slow re-segregation. He literally just says desegregation was the wrong choice. Some binaries do exist.
Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by kennywinker on Friday December 24, 2021 @04:09AM (#29671842)
> In 1976, Bell said he came to the same conclusion in an article titled Serving Two Masters, which stated, "Our clients' aims for better schooling for their children no longer meshed with integrationist ideals. Civil rights lawyers were misguided in requiring racial balance of each school's student population as the measure of compliance and the guarantee of effective schooling. In short, while the rhetoric of integration promised much, court orders to ensure that black youngsters received the education they needed to progress would have achieved much more."

https://news.stanford.edu/news/2004/april21/brownbell-421.ht...

You're really keen to broaden writing about this single moment in history to apply it to all instances of racial segregation in the US. All he says is that given the choice between racial balance in schools as the target for the supreme court, and effective schooling as the target - he says that he believes the former failed where the latter might have succeeded. That's not "I support segregation" as your binary suggests - that's "desegregation didn't achieve equality, and we had another path available that might have gotten us farther". Nowhere in that is "and we should never desegregate" or "bring back separate water fountains".

Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by fknorangesite on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @04:35PM (#29655651)
> Nobody cares that you teach the history of racism in the US

Have you missed the latest conservative boogeyman of "critical race theory"?

> correctly educate children about the civil war and slavery

On the contrary: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost_Cause_of_the_Confederacy

Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by woobilicious on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @06:45PM (#29656924)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_race_theory#Common_...

> Critique of liberalism...Critique of liberalism: First and foremost to CRT legal scholars in 1993, was their "discontent" with the way in which liberalism addressed race issues in the U.S. They critiqued "liberal jurisprudence" including affirmative action,[86] color-blindness, role modeling, and the merit principle.[87] They said that the liberal concept—value-neutral law— contributed to maintenance of the U.S. racially unjust social order.

> Storytelling/counterstorytelling and 'naming one's own reality'":': The use of narrative (storytelling) to illuminate and explore lived experiences of racial oppression.

This doesn't sound like history or science, it sounds like personal, highly subjective anecdotes, maybe even propaganda (see Jussie Smollett).

> Revisionist interpretations of American civil rights law and progress.

this doesn't sound like teaching objective historical facts.

> Cultural nationalism/separatism: The exploration of more radical views that argue for separation and reparations as a form of foreign aid (including black nationalism).

Because we definitely want to teach our kids segregation is good.

Now tell me how CRT is actually teaching objective historical facts?

Because in my eyes, this is not a philosophy that cares about facts, or liberal values, or even racism.

Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by kennywinker on Thursday December 23, 2021 @02:15AM (#29659475)
>> Revisionist interpretations of American civil rights law and progress.

> this doesn't sound like teaching objective historical facts.

A revisionist means "examining and trying to change existing beliefs about how events happened or what their importance or meaning is"

I.e. we've understood the facts incorrectly, let's take another look to try to understand them correctly. This is literally what people who study history do every day. I read a great blog recently dispelling myths about what medieval life was like. Definitely revisionist, super interesting.

Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by vorpalhex on Thursday December 23, 2021 @11:57AM (#29663682)
Revisionism:

> noun Advocacy of the revision of an accepted, usually long-standing view, theory, or doctrine, especially a revision of historical events and movements.

> noun A recurrent tendency within the Communist movement to revise Marxist theory in such a way as to provide justification for a retreat from the revolutionary to the reformist position.

Via https://www.wordnik.com/words/revisionism

CRT, Critical Racial Theory, is a Marxist tradition. I don't mean Marxist as "bad" or "scary" but I mean as in descended from the Frankfurt School of thought which focused on the Marxist tradition.

CRT uses Revisionist reading as a tool to formulate reform of an existing system or dialog. It is a Trotsky-esque tactic of reading material with a preconceived notion to find a new end.

Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by kennywinker on Thursday December 23, 2021 @02:57PM (#29665801)
The second definition doesn't mean "revisionist" has some different meaning within marxist thinking. It means communists call people who back pedal the revolutionary language of marx to make it less radical "revisionists". The meaning is the same, it's just a special context where what you are revising and why are clearly defined.

> CRT uses Revisionist reading as a tool to formulate reform of an existing system or dialog.

The only way that re-interpreting the past as a tool to figure out how to change current systems is a bad thing, is if current systems are good. Given how things are for non-white people in america, I think it's clear that changing current systems is needed.

If you're worried because they are interpreting historical fact to fit their preconceived notion, well... yes, so are we all. We all have preconceived notions. Romans were clean and noble, while medieval people were filthy and never bathed. Every story I hear about either of those times is slotted into my preconceptions about romans or medieval people. Then one day an activist historian with an agenda teaches me that romans didn't have soap, but medieval people did... the facts support their idea that medieval people were cleaner than we portray them in movies and tv. Just because they had an agenda (the medieval period is maligned in culture) when they went looking for those facts, doesn't mean they're wrong.

Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by vorpalhex on Thursday December 23, 2021 @03:37PM (#29666177)
The romans had soap and were well aware of both lye and unrefined ammonia for cleansing. They actually used ammonia for laundering clothes. Medieval people had soap too, but probably used a different process for making it than romans. (As to who was cleaner, it depends heavily on class, region and specific year.)

That's the problem with preconceived notions, they lead to bad scholarship. It's what made so many victorian era analysis of historic artifacts so poor - they were trying to reconstruct them with Victorian values.

No person can be truly neutral but you do your best to set aside preconceived notions. CRT argues that in some cases we shouldn't do that and reinforces storytelling - a fictional process - as an interpretive lens. That is not aligned with traditional scholarship and part of why Critical Theorists (at large) reject traditional scholarship. CRT is not a fact based tradition. (Crits would say it is a "critical" one)

Revisionism in the marxist dialogue is a distinct phenomenon from revisionism in general, see https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revisionism_(Marxism) and https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1908/apr/03.htm

CRT is a Marxist tradition but instead of a class divide it views through the fundamental lens of a racial divide. Just as the class divide is innate in Marxism so it is too in CRT. Re-reading existing texts to "contextualize" them and reframe them in alignment with this racial divide is the usage of Revisionism in the CRT (and likewise for fellow Critical Theories) nomenclature.

You can reject CRT wholesale AND still petition for better racial equality or the correcting of faults in any given country. CRT is not the only solution, nor does a rejection of CRT mean you accept the world as it is currently.

Re:How Activist Teachers Recruit Kids by kennywinker on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:44AM (#29671664)
So... my point was that we have a cultural bias towards representing the romans as clean and medieval people as dirty - "As to who was cleaner, it depends heavily on class, region and specific year." So you agree with the core of the idea I was presenting, but you then immediately dismiss it as bad scholorship. Apologies, I didn't think I needed to google the details for this conversation - but let's correct the record: romans didn't have soap during the republican era, but they did during the roman empire. At least by 200CE, perhaps as much as a century earlier. Happy?

> That's the problem with preconceived notions, they lead to bad scholarship

I agree. E.g. missing the forest for the trees. As you just did.