While I’d have loved us to have infite manpower getting all the security features in from day 1, we had to bootstrap and we prioritised usable apps over optimising for a perfect spec. And judging by some of the rest of the thread, we didn’t so well even then; it would have been even worse otherwise.
> While I’d have loved us to have infite manpower getting all the security features in from day 1, we had to bootstrap and we prioritised usable apps over optimising for a perfect spec.
I get the decision. But it leaves a sour taste in my mouth that Matrix advertises itself as "secure" but almost any user is leaking sensitive information without knowing. I suspect that 95% of users would be surprised if you told them about the number of things that leak in E2EE rooms. Probably the better approach would have been to skip pushing E2EE as the default, and disable all insecure features in Element for E2EE rooms (or have an explicit opt-in). The marketing team would hate this approach but it least it is honest and safe.
Sending things unencrypted that users have every reason to think are encrypted is extremely irresponsible. And I assumed, as I think is perfectly reasonable, that everything in an E2EE room is in fact end-to-end encrypted. I'm very disappointed to find out this way that it's not (and won't be for the foreseeable future), and I don't see any justification for failing to making users aware of that.
All that said, I love Matrix, will continue to use it every day, and am hugely rooting for the success of the project. Thanks for all your hard work on it!
Why couldn't the client simply count the number of reactions?
I can't imagine it'd be a performance issue. After all, if you didn't have reactions you'd have a bunch of in-band "+ 1" comments; if such a thing would bring down the server then I'd assume you'd have much bigger problems.
Edit: clarification
Breaking this expectation is a massive red flag, particularly because Matrix is often chosen with this expectation at the core of the decision.
Is this not the case for e.g. Signal reactions?
The text/content of the edit itself is actually encrypted, you can check in Element by viewing the event in de/encrypted form
This is one place where I strongly disagree.
Almost all features have "We will add encryption later" which is not a way to build a secure messenger. Stickers, polls, profiles, spaces, relations, reactions... they all start with and unencrypted version with the promise that "encryption will come in a later MSC". They should really take "secure" out of the tagline until they actually add E2EE for all of these features. Basically all clients allow users to use these insecure features in encrypted rooms with no warning at all.
And I constantly see hacky quick fixes get accepted because "we need to do something", "no clear use case for $X" (even when there is) and "N other MSCs depend on this so we'll merge it in and deal with a proper solution later". For example the relations MSC just got merged with support for only 1 relation per message even though it is clear that editing replies would be a problem with this system.
I love Matrix and hope it does in fact unify messaging but I think "carefully" is not the way to describe how the spec is progressing. More like "shoved in whatever direction is needed to implement the newest Element feature". Maybe that is for the better, we do need a featureful protocol to get users after all, but personally it irks me the wrong way. Especially when security and privacy are ignored "for later".