News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by Devasta on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @09:10AM (#29649473)
Monolithic browser controlled by Google is already the case, the corpse of firefox is being dangled about "Weekend at Bernies" style so they can pretend they don't control the web.

Chromes dominance is not going to be changed outside of government action.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by hestefisk on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @10:59AM (#29651018)
I use FF every day and it works really well for my purposes. I do all of my daily desktop browsing in it and only open Chrome if I need to access an internal corporate web site on my work laptop. To me, FF isn’t a dangling corpse, it works well and it’s just not fair to the devs at Mozilla to make such a harsh statement.
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by throw10920 on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @04:14PM (#29655304)
Statcounter says that Firefox has about a 4% worldwide market share, compared to Chrome's 64%[1]. Assuming that the parent poster was talking about Firefox's quality instead of market share is more than a little presumptuous.

[1] https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by justsomehnguy on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @10:02PM (#29658183)
> I use FF every day and it works really well for my purposes

Good for you, but the problem is what many other people don't use FF in any way, even if it worked well for their purposes.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by ahaseeb on Sunday December 26, 2021 @08:14PM (#29697998)
Hard to get adoption purely based on privacy. Privacy is a super hard sell
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by ravenstine on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @10:14AM (#29650358)
I agree, though I think your characterization isn't entirely fair.

Firefox might have become irrelevant in terms of market share, but it's far from being a "corpse", if you meant anything by that outside of the "Weekend at Bernie's" analogy. It works quite well, its extensions are far less likely to get totally nerfed for the purpose of showing ads, and it even still develops features before Chrome does.

It's definitely being dangled out there for the sake of excusing Google, but it also seems like someone's seriously holding it back. The Servo debacle was pretty inexcusable. Servo of course still exists under the Linux Foundation, but we'll be lucky if we ever see it mean anything to Firefox or become anything other than a curiosity.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by dimitrios1 on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @10:09AM (#29650301)
This is assuming quite a few things:

1. We the people are completely unable to use the power of market forces to come up with an alternative and supplant the established market leader

2. The government will regulate this in a way that is better than the alternative

3. That lobbying forces and the general corruption that is widespread in D.C. won't impact that in any negative way.

4. That big tech companies aren't experts in skirting regulations or that Google doesn't already have a plan B if something happened to one of their moats.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by stjohnswarts on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @12:04PM (#29652037)
Market forces generally cannot stop a monopoly without government interaction. It's simply too powerful. They either buy upstarts or sue them into destruction in court. The only other way is if technology has a huge shift and the monopoly can't keep up before an interloper comes in and disrupts. That doesn't look to be happening anytime soon. I only see "Web3" and "Metaverse" and neither of those really spark joy in most people.
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by dimitrios1 on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @03:08PM (#29654356)
Chrome does not even come close to meeting the definition of a monopoly. Google is not "unreasonably restraining competition" nor is it even selling its browser.

Besides that point, you have to be keen to distinguish between a situation where there is just a clear market winner versus a company attempting to monopolize, e.g. do people just prefer to use Chrome at the end of the day? Most internet users today are aware of Microsoft's browser. Almost all millennials and under are additionally aware of Firefox. The definition of monopoly isn't just "people choose to use this product in lieu of others" but something closer to "people are forced to use this product in lieu of others" or "people have no other choice than to use this product"

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by sirwhinesalot on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @06:09PM (#29656652)
Google goes out of their way to make their websites only work well in Chrome (and Safari, somewhat).

This killed the original non-chromium Edge. Not sure if it fits a monopoly definition but it is definitely not good behaviour.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by stjohnswarts on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:57AM (#29659077)
A lot of people won't think outside of the box and see that the definition of monopoly has to evolve with the times. It's not the early 1900's any longer, big tech is redefining the way we need to address lots of things.
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by dimitrios1 on Thursday December 23, 2021 @09:57AM (#29662399)
The CURRENT_YEAR fallacy is never a convincing argument, but especially not here considering the last significant anti trust action was one taken out against Microsoft for very related things.

We've had "Big Tech" and monopolizing actions amongst them for a while now.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by 9dev on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:37AM (#29671618)
Parent is right though. We didn’t have global tech empires with that kind of leverage at the time the monopoly laws were created. By spreading a browser for free, Google gains control in many subtle ways that eventually lead to revenue. That is definitely dangerous, although it doesn’t fit a classical monopoly.
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by ahaseeb on Sunday December 26, 2021 @08:16PM (#29698013)
Reason for crypto popularity is mostly due to financial upside. If you remove that, web3 or crypto will fail
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by selfhoster11 on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @11:53AM (#29651864)
Re: point number 1 - market forces can't fix lack of DRM support in a browser made completely from scratch. Even Spotify, and sometimes news sites ask to enable EME now (which I refuse out of principle). A brand-new browser already got squashed by Google's refusal to allow Widevine modules to run on said browser, and if DRM becomes a commodity solution, it's goodbye to the open market of web browsers.
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by dimitrios1 on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @03:18PM (#29654520)
But you just said the crux if the issue: you refuse out of principle, but that doesn't mean others share your principles.

Why did Google's refusal squash a brand new browser? Why was it even a factor? Did it have to be? Is there an alternative approach one could take to not need google's involvement to include a Widevine module in their said brand-new browser?

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by selfhoster11 on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @05:06PM (#29656069)
My refusal to allow EME content is entirely my own decision, and irrelevant to the point I'm trying to make.

My point was that DRM (EME) support is becoming an expectation, and you are outright locked out from certain EME schemes like Widevine unless you're a "blessed" browser (which you can't be, yet - by definition, you're too small to enter any meaningful communication with a large player, as the browser I mentioned found out).

> Why did Google's refusal squash a brand new browser? Why was it even a factor? Did it have to be?

Said browser (Metastream [0]) was meant to build a different experience for watching video streams together, potentially including DRM-ed sources. Widevine allegedly has a 70% market share, so the refusal really was a big deal and a deal-breaker for the intended vision of the browser.

> Is there an alternative approach one could take to not need google's involvement to include a Widevine module in their said brand-new browser?

What do you propose, beyond technical workarounds that can cease working at any time? I imagine that there may be a risk of invoking the DMCA or lawsuits, whether wrongful or not (might makes right after all, and Google has the deeper pockets here)

The right way to do this is to engage into a DRM licensing process, which is a fundamentally business-based one. And when you're small and dealing with a stubborn large business, there's no right to appeal their decision.

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19553941

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by keithnz on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @05:05PM (#29656059)
if you look at the stats in the US, chrome is slightly less than 50%, safari has a much bigger slice of the pie (with edge a wee bit more popular than the worldwide trend)
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by phkahler on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @09:32AM (#29649815)
>> Chromes dominance is not going to be changed outside of government action.

Well not with that attitude.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by selfhoster11 on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @11:54AM (#29651880)
What do you propose instead of government action? Turning up as a crowd with pitchforks outside of the Google HQ?
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by lamontcg on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:09AM (#29658866)
People start using firefox?
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by ahaseeb on Sunday December 26, 2021 @08:17PM (#29698020)
People SHOULD do a lot of things but ultimately distribution wins. If IE comes with OS, they'll use it. It's similar to people using windows or whatever OS is by default.
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by mfer on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @09:15AM (#29649557)
> Chromes dominance is not going to be changed outside of government action.

This is because business tactics rather than technical or product ones are the reason for their domination.

While I love technologies, it's so important to focus on the things outside of the tech itself at times.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by Devasta on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @09:21AM (#29649654)
Tbh a lot of the tech is business tactics. Pumping so much stuff into the browser makes it an impossible task just trying to maintain feature parity nevermind compete on quality.

Building out a high quality subset is not viable, the second your browser stops working with Amazon or Ebay or whatever else your browser is finished.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by mfer on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @09:29AM (#29649773)
> Pumping so much stuff into the browser makes it an impossible task just trying to maintain feature parity nevermind compete on quality.

To compete or gain a market doesn't mean you need to have all the features. Doing things differently can and does work. The more I read books like Competing Against Luck and The Design Of Everyday Things the more I'm able to see it and even work on projects that do that.

> the second your browser stops working with Amazon or Ebay or whatever else your browser is finished

This is why standards are so important. Why it's important to have Firefox and Safari in the marketplace. Apple using Safari on iOS and iOS large market helps keep the standards ecosystem in check with Chromes dominance.

The lack of modern tech communications standards is causing problems for consumers. While I don't always like the HTML, CSS, and JS specs... the fact that we have specs and multiple implementations is a benefit to people who want to try and compete.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by kaba0 on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @09:49AM (#29650031)
When it comes to a platform which’s only redeeming quality is that it is a standard, then not following that standard is quite dump in my opinion.
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by _fat_santa on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @10:22AM (#29650458)
> Chromes dominance is not going to be changed outside of government action.

Is it the dominance of 'Chrome' or 'Chromium'. I see 'Chrome' as Google's official product, 'Chromium' though seems to have become a boilerplate in recent years for kickstarting your own browser, and I don't know how I feel about this.

On the one hand Google is already a monopoly in the browser space, because we have gone from "Browser Wars" to "Engine Wars" where 3 distinct browsers (Edge, Chrome and Brave) all running the same tech from Google.

On the other hand I see this as a major service Google has done to help everyone in web development. In a way this engine monopoly has made things much easier, I no longer care if you're running Chrome, Edge, Brave or some other V8 based browser, I know I will see a consistent experience across those browsers. And while part of me is fearful or this shift, another part of me is like "so what". So what if Chromium is a dominant browser "core", it's OSS and though Google has major influence, it's still OSS.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by pc86 on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @10:36AM (#29650656)
Chrome (not Chromium) has something like 63% global market share. I'm not sure Brave, with its ~1%, is worth talking about unless you're also talking about Vivaldi and Opera and every niche browser that exists.

Sincerely, a happy Brave user.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by SllX on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @10:26AM (#29650517)
> Chromes dominance is not going to be changed outside of government action.

Heard this once already when the song was about IE6.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by diputsmonro on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @10:30AM (#29650574)
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by SllX on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @10:42AM (#29650743)
IE6 post-dates the conclusion of this lawsuit, and held ~90% of browser, not desktop browser, but browser market share for the better part of the next decade.

What changed? Firefox was released, Safari was released, and quite a bit later, Google Chrome was released, but it would still be a while before IE6 would lose its dominance even once IE7 was released.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by JohnBooty on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @11:04AM (#29651106)
Key differences between this situation and IE6/7:

1. IE6/7 were just egregiously bad experiences for both users and developers, with Microsoft being almost entirely disinterested to the point of disbanding their browser team. Holding the web back was clearly part of their strategy.

2. Chrome, on the other hand, is well-maintained and rather good. Unlike Microsoft in the 2000s, the web is a core pillar of Google's business. Any challenger to the throne will have to overtake a moving target powered by a world-class engineering powerhouse, rather than a static dinosaur like IE6/IE7.

3. The barrier to entry in the browser market today is roughly an order of magnitude greater than it was back then. Browsers today are far more complex; they're more like operating systems.

As far as the free market is concerned, nobody is seriously challenging Chrome in this area. Ever. Unless/until Google loses interest and stops competing.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by SllX on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @11:35AM (#29651558)
All of your criticisms of IE6 are fair and on point, but if you recall IE7 was Microsoft putting the gang back together again and trying to put some effort in again. Still not a great browser, but still a marked point where they abandoned their abandonment of Internet Explorer as a project.

Google also originally piggy backed on WebKit to build their browser. The JavaScript runtime was homegrown, but Google worked within WebKit before forking out of there. My guess is when Google Chrome is eventually overtaken, it will be by another Chromium-based browser under similar circumstances.

The web also isn’t just desktop browsers anymore. It’s much harder to make the case that Google Chrome is the only major browser of concern with MobileSafari running around, and per Apple’s policies, WebKit the only useful browser engine on iOS and iPadOS.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by JohnBooty on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @03:09PM (#29654363)

    The web also isn’t just desktop browsers anymore. It’s much
    harder to make the case that Google Chrome is the only major 
    browser of concern with MobileSafari running around, and per 
    Apple’s policies, WebKit the only useful browser engine on iOS 
    and iPadOS. 
Yeah and, perhaps I'm giving them too much credit for strategy/foresight, but it feels like this all plays precisely into Google's hands.

There is just enough competition, and Google's web apps are just functional enough on Webkit/Firefox, for Google to sail clear of accusations of monopoly.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by SllX on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @03:19PM (#29654534)
Well, not sure what to tell you mate. You can make the case that Google Chrome is a monopoly that should be brought to heel by the Law, under new legislation if necessary, or you can’t.

Again, I don’t even particularly like Google Chrome, but do you know the only reason I keep a Chromium-based browser installed at all is? Government websites. Not Chrome though, currently it’s Brave with all the crypto stuff turned off. I don’t even need one for anything else. To the extent that Google Chrome is entrenched, it’s the same entities whose powers you mean to bring to bear on them helping them stay entrenched.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by sydbarrett74 on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @05:19PM (#29656214)
Some of us feel trepidation about Chrome being 'too big to fail' simply because Google has demonstrated itself to be capricious and fickle in terms of continued support for products. One only has to glance at killedbygoogle.com to see a pattern of rather arbitrary decisions to kill various things. If for any reason Google decided to kill off Chrome, it would be nice to have an alternative to fall back upon.
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by selfhoster11 on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @11:56AM (#29651903)
The web is 10x more complicated now. Firefox's challenge was being bug-compatible with IE, but the challenge now is replicating the entire browser runtime.
Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by SllX on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @12:18PM (#29652242)
Does the web being 10x more complicated mean that 1. Google Chrome, which full disclosure: isn’t my browser of choice, deserves the same end as Internet Explorer? And 2. That the government is the means by which it should be brought to heel?

I mentioned this in another comment, but Google Chrome originally piggybacked on WebKit, homegrown JS runtime aside, before forking out of there. I think there’s a decent chance that the same could happen to Google via another Chromium-based browser. Just because it’s not immediately apparent how Chrome will lose its dominance today doesn’t mean it won’t ever happen. Nor does that mean it should. People actually like Chrome. I used to like Chrome, and it’s easy to see how people with a different set of priorities than mine still do.

The old song was about IE6, and today’s song is about Google Chrome. The lyrics might be different but it’s still the same old song.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by selfhoster11 on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @04:44PM (#29655778)
I don't want to see Chrome (and Chromium) die, I merely want to see other browser engines flourish. Heck, even Trident, if we could turn back time and have Explorer become a good web citizen.

My problem with Chrome dominance is that it's both a dominance of a single company (since Chrome is by far the dominant "fork" of Chromium, and owned by an advertising corporation), and a dominance of a single browser engine. The latter is IMO a really big threat, as it leads to browser engine monoculture. Monoculture leads to a single point of failure, and in this case, a loss of knowledge about how to build a browser engine that's "the websites that are actually out there"-compliant. Much more relies on the web now, so it's paramount that we have a useful alternative browser engine implementation.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by SllX on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @09:41PM (#29658047)
Sure, but what’s the original sin at work here? Google investing their time and resources into their browser projects, or the fact that web became this complex mess because web developers beat the drum for 15 going on 20 years that the web should be an app runtime?

Duplicating an app runtime feature for feature and bug for bug is difficult in a capital intensive sort of way. Even companies that can afford the expenditure, primarily Microsoft, decided to get out of that game because that level of expenditure comes with its own opportunity costs even at their level.

And there are alternatives: WebKit and Mozilla, one of those is the exclusive web renderer for iPhones and iPads which is not an insignificant amount of hardware in the world.

Google puts the work in. It’s really just that, and it’s their private prerogative to put that work in if they so choose, where others choose not to. The diversity of rendering engines isn’t great compared to say 15 years ago, but it’s not so bad that it’s a total monoculture in the way IE6 was. Actually thinking about it, more people are using more and different browser rendering engines than back then because Chromium-based browsers don’t have the total dominance that IE6 did, and there’s a lot more people on the web than there used to be. We had diversity, but we’re talking iCab, pre-WebKit OmniWeb, Opera on Presto, and yeah, Trident’s not really around anymore, but it was there, and so was Gecko and WebKit.

At least you don’t need a browser that supports ActiveX controls for regular websites anymore.

Re:Now DuckDuckGo is building its own desktop browser by sydbarrett74 on Wednesday December 22, 2021 @05:13PM (#29656141)
I respectfully disagree. If Mozilla can lessen its dependence on hush-money from Google, that is a /good/ thing. One may believe that Firefox/Gecko is an animated corpse, but it's the only realistic alternative to the Chromium ecosystem that we currently have. Other rendering engines are too obscure to matter and/or the hobbyist project of one person or at best a small team, including Palemoon and its ilk.