Re:Apple vs. Microsoft: Which user interface do you prefer?
by makeramen on Tuesday September 06, 2011 @05:18PM
(#2967340)
The resizing behavior you outline for the Ribbon is actually a horrible UI design decision for repeat actions, which most are.
Example:
If a user remembers the "Copy" button as the first big button, or paste as the third little button, etc. Next time you open the window at a different resolution, or you resize, everything changes. Your positional memory of this button is gone. I absolutely hate the Ribbon's design for this. (I don't have windows running, so I'm making this up as an example, but I know it has happened to me before)
I prefer apple's "old" menu design over the Ribbon. Albeit seemingly archaic, it's actually a very useful place to store multiple commands in easily readable text that never changes position (especially on a mac, where the menu is always at the top toolbar).
Re:Apple vs. Microsoft: Which user interface do you prefer?
by Jamiecon on Tuesday September 06, 2011 @01:31PM
(#2966389)
Conveniently enough, this article has a helpful graph of the most common screen resolutions on Windows:
https://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2011/08/26/improvements-...
Re:Apple vs. Microsoft: Which user interface do you prefer?
by camtarn on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @07:14AM
(#2969127)
Interesting - the most common resolution is even wider than I thought. Thanks for pointing that out - I'd read the article not long ago but had forgotten about that particular point :)
Try resizing the Ribbon all the way from super-wide (if you've got dual monitors, it's particularly interesting) to really narrow. It's quite fun to watch, especially in Office products with zillions of interface controls - the giant buttons and large scrollable boxes full of options become groups of smaller buttons with text, then even smaller buttons without text, then collapse into a single menu, before disappearing altogether into the 'more' button.