Re:The Great Offline
by dragonwriter on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @08:47PM
(#29644634)
> There are real questions about what makes people want to change sex
But they aren't what drive either side of the trans rights debate...
> about the effects of immigration
...or the immigration debate...
> and about the effects of social spending.
...or most social spending debate.
In all of those cases, the differences are primarily over values, and the factual views often are overlapping between the sides and quite diverse within each side.
And where there are important fact disputes, often one (or both) sides rejects (often explicitly) empricism in favor of some other source of understanding on the issue, making fact debate fruitless. (It doesn't help you reach consensus that your opponent's position is grounded in a falsifiable fact claim if they view the fact belief as justified by divine revelation and not subject to empirical inquiry.)
Empirical inquiry into facts is good for resolving policy disputes between people who agree on the relevant value criteria and agree on empiricism as the correct epistemic framework for the fact inquiry, but, as it turns out, most important policy disputes are not between sides where that is the case. (Policy disputes within certain factions sometimes have this quality, but those between political—usually ideological—factions tend not to.)
But they aren't what drive either side of the trans rights debate...
> about the effects of immigration
...or the immigration debate...
> and about the effects of social spending.
...or most social spending debate.
In all of those cases, the differences are primarily over values, and the factual views often are overlapping between the sides and quite diverse within each side.
And where there are important fact disputes, often one (or both) sides rejects (often explicitly) empricism in favor of some other source of understanding on the issue, making fact debate fruitless. (It doesn't help you reach consensus that your opponent's position is grounded in a falsifiable fact claim if they view the fact belief as justified by divine revelation and not subject to empirical inquiry.)
Empirical inquiry into facts is good for resolving policy disputes between people who agree on the relevant value criteria and agree on empiricism as the correct epistemic framework for the fact inquiry, but, as it turns out, most important policy disputes are not between sides where that is the case. (Policy disputes within certain factions sometimes have this quality, but those between political—usually ideological—factions tend not to.)