News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You can't lure employees back to the office by firebaze on Monday December 20, 2021 @05:21PM (#29631147)
With this policy, you'll keep the 20% capable staff. Anyone else (except a few both too afraid to leave and too comfy with their current pay) will leave.

That'll leave you with a few 10x staff, too lazy to leave, but capable, and a lot of ballast.

Re:You can't lure employees back to the office by kozikow on Monday December 20, 2021 @05:27PM (#29631208)
I forgot to add that our office is not in San Francisco, so you can get decently priced apartment within walking distance to the office, without people injecting heroin at your front door and a good public transport.
Re:You can't lure employees back to the office by chefkoch on Monday December 20, 2021 @05:26PM (#29631193)
I think you underestimate how many people like the socialising in the office if you have a relativly short commute.
Re:You can't lure employees back to the office by nightski on Monday December 20, 2021 @05:38PM (#29631375)
I used to like it. About 10 years ago I went into consulting from home. I've developed much richer friendships outside of the office and like to go out in the evenings with them instead of coworkers. I've also become more engaged with my local technology/software community. It's nice to be able to lose a client or job and not worry about losing my friends.

YMMV.

Re:You can't lure employees back to the office by codegeek on Monday December 20, 2021 @05:47PM (#29631477)
Now think about you when you did like it. What was your situation/life back then ? There are plenty of people who are you from that time. They do like going into office. So the argument here is that it is not one size fits all and just like there are plenty of arguments FOR wfh, there are plenty against it. YMMV
Re:You can't lure employees back to the office by nightski on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:05PM (#29631668)
No need to be defensive, I agree with you. Both sides are valid. But according to the OP employers want to kill WFH, not vice versa.

I will say though thinking back to those times I was younger and more naive. I was a slave to that employer, often there until 8-9 at night. My life revolved around them. It wasn't healthy.

Re:You can't lure employees back to the office by codegeek on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:16PM (#29631759)
No worries. I am also not arguing for office only and if employers are trying to kill WFH completely, that is a bad move and will not work.
Re:You can't lure employees back to the office by loco5niner on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:42PM (#29642450)
I prefer socializing with the people of my choosing
Re:You can't lure employees back to the office by adjkant on Monday December 20, 2021 @05:54PM (#29631567)
Your points weighs heavily on a lot of implicit parts of the value equation you left out.

1. That 20% number. What if it's 40%? 50%?

2. How easy/quick is it to replace the people you will lose who don't prefer this work style?

3. What percentage of your current workforce likes the environment as described? Maybe hiring off the street is 20%, but you've already selected for 80% through other selection factors.

Basically, at what point does the value gained from the in person work / setup overtake the loss of potential workforce? You're making an argument for why some people won't want to work there, but so long as the environment is not discriminating on things like race/gender/ability, a partial in person setup may actually be the right call for some teams/companies, without any "luring" needed.

I say all this as someone who primarily prefers to work at home now, but goes into the office once a week or so without any requirement to do so. I agree with OP's initial points a lot, though I think I would lean less towards requirements and more towards guides.

Re:You can't lure employees back to the office by R0b0t1 on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:00PM (#29631617)
For 1 it's the Pareto distribution. I've seen it normal that 80% of the people do 20% of the work, and the top 20% do 80% of it. He's saying you'll keep the lower 80%.
Re:You can't lure employees back to the office by adjkant on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:02PM (#29631640)
Ah, I misunderstood then.

I see that as a total misapplication then, as it actually assumes way worse - that 100% of the people would not like this work condition described, which is evidently false as OP has a company of people working in that. The question still remains though: what percentage of people would choose to stay / join this environment?