News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by badRNG on Monday December 20, 2021 @02:51PM (#29629307)
I think the idea that we are in a unique time of civil strife is a myth.

From the actual Civil War, to the militant labor movement, to the first red scare, to McCarthyism and the Civil Rights Movement, to the anti-Vietnam war movement, American civil life has been defined by conflict.

Maybe social media allows conflict to be persistently on the top of people's minds. While in previous years one may have enjoyed the privilege of conflict not following you home, following you on vacation, and following you to the toilet.

The barricades aren't in the street, they're in your Facebook groups or Twitter threads, and they need to be persistently manned in order to ensure territory isn't lost to the other side.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by notacoward on Monday December 20, 2021 @03:57PM (#29630201)
> American civil life has been defined by conflict.

How many times has the Capitol been stormed? How many times has it been possible for a party representing a clear minority of citizens (however defined) to gain or hold on to power via gerrymandering, rejection of votes, or state-legislative nullification of results? When, in the past, has it been possible and to a large extent legal for corporations and hostile foreign powers to influence our elections in a significant way? At least some things that are happening now are unprecedented (even if we disagree on the exact set).

Also, please note that the authors have actually studied what other changes act as precursors to civil war throughout the world. Perhaps we shouldn't put our own intuition above that, without at least considering the evidence they present.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by raxxorrax on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:56AM (#29635427)
If you blame everything that is bad on your political opponent as a group, you make yourself a tool for others to be exploited. And political parties will do that in any case. Not because they are evil, this is just the dynamics of public relations, elections or not, democracy or not.
Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by areyousure on Monday December 20, 2021 @05:49PM (#29631498)
> How many times has the Capitol been stormed?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_violent_and_danger...

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by notacoward on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:43PM (#29631980)
So, not many. I didn't use "stormed" by accident. It means an armed group forcing their way past defenders into contested territory. A lone crazy doesn't count. An internal altercation doesn't count. Those are violent, but not storming, and AFAICT the last incident of that was 1814. Thanks for proving my point about how exceptional January 6 was.
Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by drewcoo on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:59AM (#29635441)
It's possible to wordsmith a anything into a tiny set of just one truly unique thing. People do this with subjects such as intelligence, gods, and favorite athletes all the time. While this rhetoric tugs on my heart, it has no effect on truth value of any claim.
Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by pseudo0 on Monday December 20, 2021 @07:49PM (#29632468)
None of the people who entered the Capitol were armed, at least according to the charges brought by prosecutors (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_charges_in_the_2021_U...), and the only person shot that day was a rioter. I don't blame you for having misconceptions though, legacy media coverage of this topic has been absolutely abysmal.
Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by dragonwriter on Monday December 20, 2021 @09:05PM (#29632968)
> None of the people who entered the Capitol were armed

False:

(1) several people were charged for having and using weapons within the Capitol [0], and

(2) Even if none were specifically charged with using weapons, that would not support “None were armed...according to charges” only “None were charged with being armed”

[0] from: https://www.justice.gov/usao-dc/capitol-breach-cases

Zachary Jordan Alam with Remaining in a Restricted Building with a Deadly or Dangerous Weapon, and with Engaging in Physical Violence in a Restricted Building with a Deadly or Dangerous Weapon;

Christopher Michael Alberts with both firearms offenses and disorderly conduct within a Capitol Building (note that while some of the firearms offenses were in the initial complaint and statement of facts, the full combination including disorderly conduct inside the Capitol is in the Second Superceding Indictment—the third version of the charges based on additional information.)

...and that's not even the whole way through the A’s.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by pseudo0 on Monday December 20, 2021 @09:39PM (#29633186)
When I said armed, it's pretty clear by context that I was referring to firearms. And fair enough, the Wikipedia page appears to be out of date, as it does look like Alberts and Ibrahim were charged with having firearms on Capitol grounds. Although Ibrahim was a DEA agent who was charged for LARPing and doing a photoshoot of himself in front of the Capitol with his DEA badge and gun, so that's going to be an entertaining one for the government to explain.

Still, your characterization of this as an "armed group" is also false, as a couple individual idiots bringing firearms to a riot is obviously entirely different than an organized squad "storming" the Capitol. One shot was fired during the entire event, and one person was killed, and that was a rioter, not a cop or a politician.

I don't have much sympathy for that crowd of idiots, but it is concerning how this event has been exaggerated into 9/11 2.0, providing an excellent excuse to crack down on civil liberties just as the justification of Islamic terrorism has receded.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by dragonwriter on Monday December 20, 2021 @10:18PM (#29633432)
> When I said armed, it's pretty clear by context that I was referring to firearms.

Yes, but that’s not what “armed” normally means, or what it was used upthread to mean, and a counterargument where you redefine terms to mean something else... isn't a counterargument, but closer to an admission.

> Alberts and Ibrahim were charged with having firearms on Capitol grounds.

Alberts was immediately charged with having a firearm on the grounds; the recent change is the charge of disorderly conduct in a Capitol building.

> Although Ibrahim was a DEA agent who was charged for LARPing and doing a photoshoot of himself in front of the Capitol with his DEA badge and gun

He was not charged with LARPing; nothing in the charges indicates he was not a serious participant.

> so that's going to be an entertaining one for the government to explain.

I don't see what’s entertaining about it, or how its any different than the handful of active duty service members charged. Yes, the government holds people accountable even when they work for the government.

> Still, your characterization of this as an "armed group" is also false

It wasn't my characterization, but it's also not false. It was a group, and they brought, forcibly stole, and used a wide variety of weapons..

> couple individual idiots bringing firearms to a riot is obviously entirely different than an organized squad "storming" the Capitol.

Among the very large groups storming the Capitol were several organized squads (the overall size of the group was much more than squad size, somewhere in the brigade-division-corps range.)

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by raxxorrax on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:58AM (#29635435)
> Although Ibrahim was a DEA agent who was charged for LARPing and doing a photoshoot of himself in front of the Capitol

That behavior does sound like substance abuse.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by notacoward on Monday December 20, 2021 @09:01PM (#29632945)
None of them had firearms you mean. The claim that they weren't armed is a transparent lie. There is a lot of video showing them carrying and using weapons of various sorts.
Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by dragonwriter on Monday December 20, 2021 @09:20PM (#29633066)
> None of them had firearms you mean

At least one person is charged with both having a firearm at the riot and disorderly conduct in Capitol building, so even that is wrong.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by karaterobot on Monday December 20, 2021 @03:04PM (#29629527)
But internet flame wars and real civil wars are not equivalent. Yes, there's always been some level of civil strife in America, just as there has in every country, at every moment in history. People argue, often angrily. But, it's not until there is actual, physical violence that it becomes a civil war. The question is, are we close to an organized faction taking up arms against the state? Anything short of that is interesting in its own way, sociologically and culturally, but it is not a civil war.
Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by drewcoo on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @03:49AM (#29635386)
I think the Business Plot was closer to civil war than any of those.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_Plot