News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by sofixa on Monday December 20, 2021 @02:44PM (#29629214)
It'd be interesting, from a neutral-ish, academic, historic, curiosity perspective, to see a civil war / revolution in a developed country with a modern industrialised military. The resultant mess can get extremely deadly and hard, if not impossible, to resolve.

That being said, i do personally think a revolution in the US has been coming for quite some and is needed to fix the broken political system ( two party model, winner take all, gerrymandering, electoral college, appointed judges, mind boggling fetishisation of an obsolete document, remnants of slavery, to name just a few). I do sincerely hope it happens as bloodlessly as possible.

(I'm currently listening to the Revolutions podcast, specifically about the Russian Revolution and resultant civil war, and i find it fascinating. Living in such historic moments ( like a pandemic) feels weird. You're there while history is being written, and heck, you might be an active participant! A blessing and a curse).

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by NikolaNovak on Monday December 20, 2021 @02:50PM (#29629299)
I've been through a civil war in a developed country with modern industrialized military. It's just a curse.
Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by f154hfds on Monday December 20, 2021 @03:09PM (#29629606)
> the broken political system ( two party model, winner take all, gerrymandering, electoral college, appointed judges, mind boggling fetishisation of an obsolete document, remnants of slavery, to name just a few)

two party model: while the two party model isn't ideal it's not always been as divisive as it is right now since ~2016. There are steps we could take at the state level that would over time make this better.

winner take all: Our system is designed to have a relatively powerful head of state while also enforcing severe limitations. The constitution mostly accomplishes this by giving the president the military but not the budget. In principle this is a difficult balance to get right. Too much power to the president and there is a run-away effect where limitations get sidestepped over time. Too little power and the federation eventually breaks apart (imagine Lincoln accepting the confederacy without a fight).

gerrymandering: This is also hard to get right. It is indicative of systemic problems that politicians can't reach an agreement that would more universally curb this undemocratic practice but it's easy to condemn these practices and much harder to propose airtight alternative solutions.

electoral college: there are pros and cons. The pros are that it works to balance power between population centers and vast rural areas by giving a slight boost to unpopulated areas over the population centers. The cons are obviously that the result of this leads to elections that are slightly off from a 'popular' vote. Feel free to dislike the rule but it is debatable at the very least.

Appointed judges: yes they're appointed at the federal level (there's a deep history to this aspect of the three branches of government), but states do it differently. In my area most of my judges by case load are elected officials.

obsolete document: again, it's easy to criticize but hard to offer alternatives that would work better. I'm weary of the lazy attempts to tear institutions down while not recognizing their incredible value. Remember this has been the defining document outlining our system of government since King George III.

Remnants of slavery: what country doesn't deal with problems stemming from its past sins? How would some sort of revolution help to fix this?

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by sofixa on Monday December 20, 2021 @03:54PM (#29630157)
I'd have to hard disagree.

> two party model: while the two party model isn't ideal it's not always been as divisive as it is right now since ~2016. There are steps we could take at the state level that would over time make this better.

Is this really the best excuse you have? It hasn't always been this bad? Are there any legitimate reasons to want or keep a two party system? That the people benefiting from it don't want it to change is a very poor excuse, and honestly i can't think of another one.

> winner take all: Our system is designed to have a relatively powerful head of state while also enforcing severe limitations. The constitution mostly accomplishes this by giving the president the military but not the budget. In principle this is a difficult balance to get right. Too much power to the president and there is a run-away effect where limitations get sidestepped over time. Too little power and the federation eventually breaks apart (imagine Lincoln accepting the confederacy without a fight)

I meant winner of a single election take all, disenfranchising anyone who didn't vote for the winner. E.g. a senator elected with 45% against another candidate with 30% represents only the 45% of the electorate who voted for them, the rest be damned. Obviously that's ridiculously stupid, and makes it so people in areas overwhelmingly disagreeing with them don't even bother voting, and aren't represented by anyone.

> gerrymandering

It's not that hard to get right, go proportional at a fixed predefined level - like a state. 10 representatives from the state, state-level elections, and the places are proportionally distributed per list/party by percent of votes.

> electoral college: there are pros and cons. The pros are that it works to balance power between population centers and vast rural areas by giving a slight boost to unpopulated areas over the population centers. The cons are obviously that the result of this leads to elections that are slightly off from a 'popular' vote. Feel free to dislike the rule but it is debatable at the very least.

To stop disenfranchising a part of the population ( rural areas), it drastically disenfranchises the vast majority of the population ( urban areas). Rural areas are already overrepresented by virtue of the fixed number of senators per state. I think that's more than enough, but i agree, it's debatable. However what's not debatable is applying the ridiculously stupid winner take all logic for that.

> Judges

I'm not saying elected judges are better than appointed by the executive, because both are pretty bad. Popular judges aren't necessarily the best ones. A mixed system whereby other judges, prosecutors and lawyers vote seems better, but that's certainly debatable.

> Slavery & constitution

Few countries explicitly allow slavery in their constitution. Or have their system of governance proportional based on number of slaves (3/5s, electoral college distribution). Most countries are capable of realising and admitted bad things, and working on making them impossible ( see Germany). The document is obsolete ( as you said yourself, it literally dates from a different time, a time with kings, slaves, the fastest travel method being a horse or a boat, literacy being rare, etc.) and needs to be rewritten before being torn down.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by f154hfds on Monday December 20, 2021 @05:25PM (#29631184)
I agree that there are problems that should be debated, solutions proposed, agreed on and implemented. What I disagree on are:

1. That a revolution would help the above process occur (namely solutions proposed/agreed on specifically). Just governance is about balance and this is incredibly hard to achieve in a vacuum if history is our guide.

2. That the problems are insurmountable. This depends on what insurmountable means. I mean that we can make progress on these issues over time using the framework of constitutional democracy. States as recently as 2018 [1] have moved towards ranked based voting.

3. That slavery is part of our constitution. 160 years ago they fought a bitter war that culminated in the outlaw of slavery. Are you arguing for reparations? That's very different from saying that slavery is baked into the constitution.

[1] https://www.maine.gov/sos/cec/elec/upcoming/rankedchoicefaq....

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by sofixa on Monday December 20, 2021 @06:06PM (#29631673)
Regarding 1, in my personal opinion the status quo seems way too entrenched. As you mention in 2, bandaids are being applied ( ranked choice voting is better than first past the post, but doesn't really fix most of the issues with US elections like gerrymandering, winner take all elections, dual party system, electoral college, unlimited campaign funding, etc.). The two parties and "establishment" have very little interest in changing things fundamentally.

Slavery is still allowed today, as punishment for a crime. The 3/5s count for stuff like the electoral college and number of house of representatives seats is still there. I'm not arguing for reparations, I think that's a whole huge debate of itself I'm not really qualified to participate in (I'm neither American nor a descendant of a slave ( more akin to colonial subjects, so quite different).

And please note, when i say revolution, I don't mean a bloody armed uprising or anything of the like, just a sudden movement for massive change. It could be brought on by a sweeping electoral victory by a reformist party, be brought upon by protests and strikes, or anything of the like.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by qohen on Monday December 20, 2021 @04:59PM (#29630887)
Few countries explicitly allow slavery in their constitution...Most countries are capable of realising and admitted bad things, and working on making them impossible

The 13th Amendment to the Constitution[0] abolished slavery back in 1789:

Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.

[0] https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/amendment-13/

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by sofixa on Monday December 20, 2021 @05:14PM (#29631069)
That's an amendment, the original constitution and other legal statutes ( e.g. 3/5 compromise) explicitly allow it and discuss it.

Furthermore, did you miss the except part in that 13th amendement? Slavery is still legal in the US, that has to be the only country that is considered developed and still does that.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by AnimalMuppet on Monday December 20, 2021 @05:21PM (#29631142)
> Or have their system of governance proportional based on number of slaves (3/5s, electoral college distribution).

Uh... you do realize that 3/5 hasn't been true for close to two centuries now? You sound like you're just grasping for something to complain about.

> Most countries are capable of realising and admitted bad things, and working on making them impossible ( see Germany).

We did. See the US Civil War.

> The document is obsolete ( as you said yourself, it literally dates from a different time, a time with kings, slaves, the fastest travel method being a horse or a boat, literacy being rare, etc.) and needs to be rewritten before being torn down.

You've argued that it's old. That doesn't make it obsolete - that's something different.

You sound like people who want to re-write their program in the new shiny language, just because it's new and shiny. That's a terribly wasteful idea. If it's broken (not just old), then fix what's broken.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by sofixa on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @05:15AM (#29635859)
> Uh... you do realize that 3/5 hasn't been true for close to two centuries now? You sound like you're just grasping for something to complain about.

Isn't the 3/5s still used as the basis for the number of representatives and electoral college members? If not, i'm sorry, i was mistaken.

> We did. See the US Civil War.

Which then resulted in Jim Crow laws and segregation, which only ended a century after said Civil War, and the effects are still visible today. Furthermore, slavery is still legal as a form of punishment.

> You've argued that it's old. That doesn't make it obsolete - that's something different.

I mentioned all the things i consider obsolete, like the broken political system. I can add a few more - slavery being legal, an electoral college existing, the current "Equal Rights Amendment" which still hasn't passed, the serious link between religion and government ( swearing on a bible counts for something), plenty of others.

The document is obsolete because it is old, doesn't contain things which are the norm in any developed country's constitution ( like equal rights between men and women), and carries significant baggage. It's like saying an old COBOL program, which has many patches for many bugs and many things it did wrong, but kind of functions, is a black box that can't be monitored, etc. needs to be rewritten in a modern language with modern tooling. There are things that are wrong with the old one, and so much so it merits a complete rewrite.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @02:46PM (#29641272)
> Isn't the 3/5s still used as the basis for the number of representatives and electoral college members? If not, i'm sorry, i was mistaken.

No. That was removed, by amendment, right after the Civil War. That language is no longer part of the Constitution.

So this gets to the question of what to do with that crufty old COBOL program. How many bugs are you going to introduce by re-writing it? How many interfaces to other programs are you going to break? Sure, it's a pain to patch it - it's difficult and time-consuming. But re-writing it has a lot of downside, even though programmers keep assuming that it will be easy and painless...

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by native_samples on Monday December 20, 2021 @05:17PM (#29631108)
Be careful what you wish for. The alternatives to the two party system are:

1. Less internally democratic parties with more side-show parties like the UK. You'd probably end up with 3 or 4 parties with name recognition, one of which acted as a kind of protest vote and occasionally came near enough to winning to be interesting, but which in reality never did. It would mean giving up things like presidential primaries.

2. PR. Look at European politics closely before deciding you want that. It's a recipe for not having a functioning/elected government for months or even a year+ after an election. In a system with elections every 4 years that'd lead to a situation where most of the time there wasn't actually any legitimate government at all and power would shift even more decisively to the civil service. There'd also be frequent collapses of government, and changes in government unconnected to any election.

3. Totalitarianism. The less said about this the better.

The US has a two party system because both Democrat and Republican parties are extremely broad and loose coalitions, so it basically never makes sense to try creating a new party instead of taking over one of the existing ones. Hence people like Trump, Bernie Sanders, etc who aren't even really connected to their host parties at all. Americans like to complain about the two party system but also like to complain about primary elections getting fixed by the party machine. Well, get rid of your current system and you're going to just formalize and institutionalize that party machine, in return for a couple more parties that most people won't vote for.

The US system has its flaws but it's not obviously worse than the alternatives. It's different, but both UK style Parliamentary systems and European style PR systems create different problems.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by rich_sasha on Monday December 20, 2021 @05:45PM (#29631455)
I’m probably biased, but European proportional representation seems to me much better than the bipolar mess of US and UK politics.

It’s true, Belgium went through a long period of not having a majority government... mind you they still had one, just without major power. But that was a major exception.

Otherwise, since it is rare that one party grabs a majority of seats on its own, it requires compromise searching. It makes big strategic moves harder, and everything is indeed a bit slower, but also less extreme and more predictable.

Parties can’t carve out their niche simply by being more extreme, so you get more of a middle ground even before you get to elections.

But also, other than various quirks of casting floats to ints, if a decision goes through parliament, it means it has the support of (MPs as of election time representing) the majority of the society. As opposed some strange nonlinear function thereof.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by native_samples on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @04:10AM (#29635484)
It's not really a bit slower. It's a lot slower. Germany has also recently gone through a long period without a legitimate government, it's not some one-off Belgian thing.

Europeans like to call what happens after an indecisive election a "caretaker government" but this is a fantasy to cover up the ugly truth - caretaker governments invariably keep ruling as if nothing had happened. They often struggle to accept that legitimacy was lost and they should do nothing, especially leftist governments that are ideologically pre-disposed to government action in the first place. Even Merkel was still turning up at global conferences and speaking for Germany months after her coalition had failed.

PR often results in bizarre, unwieldy and politically contradictory coalitions, like libertarians trying to make alliances with hard-left Greens. Hence the popularity of flag-colour names for German coalitions. The resulting governments are unstable, yield completely incoherent policymaking and frequently collapse.

In places that don't have this problem they've often evolved other deeply questionable workarounds. Switzerland has some semi-formalized mechanism for dishing out cabinet seats across parties (literally called the "magic formula"), with the result that the government is run by people who fundamentally disagree on the most critical and foundational issues of government. Worse, they constantly pretend that they don't really disagree (collective responsibility), and that this state of affairs is normal. It normalizes and institutionalizes lying to voters about their actual beliefs. The result is a federal politics that feels fake and the whole thing becomes unaccountable because the politicians end up being more loyal to each other than their voters (e.g. Berset scandals, what happened to Blocher).

I used to favour PR and thought it would be an improvement over the Parliamentary or US systems. These days I'm much more ambivalent. PR systems look more democratic on the surface but when you look at how they actually behave, I think they actually create perverse incentives. For example, the business of coalition building is pushed to politicians instead of voters themselves, although a stable society ultimately requires coalitions and understanding between citizens.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by rich_sasha on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @05:25AM (#29635912)
It's interesting. I actually didn't notice that Germany didn't have a government (it's news to me, I need to do some research).

Why did I not notice? Well, the country is functioning perfectly well. They have a coherent foreign policy. They have a coherent domestic one. A lot of their functions are devolved to local governments, so you're not relying on some centralised behemoth for everything. They are tackling Covid, I'm sure many would argue whether their decisions are right, but they are certainly efficient at implementing what they intent to do.

Germany, despite all the tropes about their efficiency, is also very bureaucratic, which affects government more than other things.

If I look at outcomes in genuinely democratic countries, I think UK and US - prime two-party democracies - come out top for dysfunctional politics.

Perhaps one misconception is that governments need to spur a constant revolution. I'd much rather see governments with stable policy, which simply keep the barrel rolling down the tracks. In that respect, the "bizzare" coalitions are a good thing - change only happens when there is broad support for it. Otherwise, you see one government come in and revolutionise, say, foreign policy, then another comes in and turns it all around again.

You point our various failures of proportional representation, I could do the same for first-past-the-post two-party politics:

- Polarisation of politics. Both parties have an incentive to pull to the extremes, almost without bound, because the only differentiation is against "the other side".

- Disconnect between popular support and the voting game. This is particularly painful in two-party systems, because the winner can easily have the minority of popular support. This used to happen regularly in the UK through "gerrymandering", I believe it happens in US in presidential elections. So you have a democratic process where the most popular candidate... loses?

- Compromise-building only happens within parties, not between parties (rare exceptions excluded). To push something through, the party needs to trade horses with its own members (generally not on grounds of merit), as opposed to with other parties (where there is scope, at least, for policy horse trading). It can go wrong in any system, but I think it is more prevalent in two-party systems. See the running joke about how every major US government project ends up with financing split among all US states, because senators all want a piece of the pie.

- Voters have almost no way to express political preferences. You can vote for 2 candidates, one of whom generally represents the opposite of your views. The idea of voting for a person, not party, is illusory IMO: MPs generally vote with their party, so it's voting for a party anyway. In proportional representation, at least you can express some mild preference as to which candidate from your party should go in, not in first-past-the-post. Whereas in proportional representation, minor parties totally can get votes, and can totally be a channel for voter preference, then in a coalition push their agenda through. This is not a bug, it's a feature.

To restate, despite appearances, European politics are rather boring and keep the lights on. The exceptions - Italy for a while or Spanish secession are so notable precisely because they are exceptions.

UK Brexit process (regardless of whether it should have happened or not) was an embarassing shitshow, US frequently is on the verge of bankrupting itself, and seems to have produced a society where two roughly equal halves hate each other.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by fennecfoxen on Monday December 20, 2021 @02:48PM (#29629264)
How modern and industrialized? Syria is a real country with MiGs and submarines.
Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by sofixa on Monday December 20, 2021 @02:54PM (#29629362)
True, but i meant a country modern and industrialised on the level of the US or Western Europe. Drones, nuclear weapons, everything digital and stuff more so than MiGs and submarines ( the latter are of somewhat limited use in a civil war, bar denying the other part supplies from overseas)
Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by notacoward on Monday December 20, 2021 @04:01PM (#29630244)
The idea that we're that different than Syria (or many other examples one could name) is just a form of exceptionalism.
Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by caeril on Tuesday December 21, 2021 @09:05AM (#29637466)
Nuclear weapons are 100% irrelevant to a potential civil war in the United States. It's not North vs. South, it's Red vs Blue, and the physical boundaries are impossible to define - the ideologues are far too evenly distributed. Even in the deepest Red areas of the country, an airburst would murder 20-30% of your own side. That's a level of collateral damage that would be unacceptable to either side.

Drones could be useful for more surgical actions, but they would be extremely reliant on accurate intelligence, which would be difficult to gather and verify in this type of theater of war. The failures of the US military to hold Afghanistan would be even more magnified at home. I don't think any of our traditional or modern military hardware would be particularly useful in an actual civil war.

Re:US ‘closer to civil war’ than most would like to believe,... by maxerickson on Monday December 20, 2021 @04:35PM (#29630619)
Turkish drones have seen wide use in Syria. I am not keeping up with the situation, but for instance:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/middle_east/turkey-dron...

https://www.forbes.com/sites/sebastienroblin/2020/03/02/idli...