Re:Clumps of human brain cells in a dish can learn to play P...
by wolverine876 on Sunday December 19, 2021 @06:55PM
(#29619926)
> outside mathematics, perfect methodology is impossible
Even in mathematics ... others on HN are better qualified than I am to comment, but I've read mathematicians say that almost no reader of a paper works out all the math; to a degree they go by reputation of the author that the mathematics is generally correct.
Similarly to your comment, while outsiders envision perfection, people inside have limited time for it. It may be more productive to spend that time on new research than on investigating every little detail of old research.
Even in mathematics ... others on HN are better qualified than I am to comment, but I've read mathematicians say that almost no reader of a paper works out all the math; to a degree they go by reputation of the author that the mathematics is generally correct.
Similarly to your comment, while outsiders envision perfection, people inside have limited time for it. It may be more productive to spend that time on new research than on investigating every little detail of old research.