I've received legit legal threats over email from very serious people. I'm certain they would have escalated to more "official" channels if the situation wasn't resolved to their satisfaction (if you're curious, it was a contractor billing issue that was being ignored by my HOA. I was caught in the crossfire).
The fact that random scammers are calling folks claiming they're violating tax law isn't a justification for researchers to engage in similar acts. Do you agree?
This is an interesting point you bring up, which merits diving into a bit further.
I think it's precisely because CCPA is so new that this experiment is more unethical than if they were just calling up people saying "you owe money to the IRS, send me gift cards". The IRS spends a ton of money every year telling people that these calls are scams; but Christine or the operator of freeradical.zone likely had no such public service announcements from the State of California. On the other hand, they probably did hear news items about this new data privacy law that California passed, and thought the emails were from actual individuals.
An email purportedly from an individual is not the same as a contract or terms of service issued by a corporation from which I am getting a service. If I, as an individual, were to send you an email asking, for example, if you are paying all the taxes you legally owe, am I just giving you "a reminder of existing laws"? Or are you going to start wondering who I am and why I am asking and wonder if something is going on behind the scenes?
> People regularly get calls saying they are in violation of tax law and must pay.
Yes, that's true. And people who make such calls are regularly considered unethical scammers who do not deserve any consideration. So why should we treat researchers who send similar emails any differently?
Or even if there is a legal threat, do you take it seriously unless you know the source? People regularly get calls saying they are in violation of tax law and must pay.