News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by Alex3917 on Sunday September 04, 2011 @11:52PM (#2961076)
Study here: http://nces.ed.gov/NAAL/PDF/2006470.PDF

There are a couple example questions in that, but if you want to understand the full methodology you'd have to read this:

http://books.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=11267

Basically the situation is that:

According to the National Adult Assessment of Literacy (NAAL), the largest and most authoritative survey of adult literacy in America, only 13% of adults are able to read English at a 'proficient' level. This means that 87% of American adults lack the minimum level of literacy skill necessary to complete simple tasks like comparing the viewpoints in two editorials or computing the cost per ounce of food items. In other words, the overwhelming majority of Americans lack the minimimum amount of education required to participate in the knowledge economy or to contribute anything meaningful to the democratic process. Source: Table 1 on p. 3, Figure 2 on p. 4. Adults unable to read prose at a 'proficient' level, by race/ethnicity: White - 83%, Asian/Pacific Islander - 88%, Hispanic - 96%, Black - 98%.

Adults unable to read prose at a 'proficient' level, by educational attainment: High school graduates - 96%, College graduates - 69%, Graduate studies/degrees - 59%. In other words, the majority of graduate students are incapable of fully understanding a newspaper, let alone an academic journal article. And virtually all high school graduates are functionally illiterate. (And again, being 'proficient' does not mean being able to read academic journal articles, which is sort of the minimum requirement for being an independent thinker in society. In fact at least 2 / 3rds of those who score 'proficient' still do not possess this more advanced measure of literacy.)

John Taylor Gatto also gives his analysis of the situation here based on the 1992 data. (The data I cited was 2003)

http://www.johntaylorgatto.com/chapters/3b.htm

http://www.johntaylorgatto.com/chapters/3j.htm

Gatto throws in a couple weasel words, and I think sometimes his analysis is a bit reaching, but overall it seems to be generally accurate. Even if you don't fully buy into the idea of an enormous decline over the last 100 years, the current methodology of the National Adult Literacy Survey seems pretty solid. (That's currently the gold standard for literacy estimates in the US.)

But what about the CIA World Factbook, which estimates that the United States has a 97% literacy rate as of 2002? Where do these figures come from? To quote from Jonathan Kozol's book Illiterate in America, "For one hundred years, starting in 1840, the census posed the question of the population's literacy level in its ten-year compilations. The government removed this question from its survey in the 1940 census. The reason, according to a U.S. Census Bureau publication, was a general conviction that 'most people [by this time] could read and write ...'

In 1970, pressured by the military, the Bureau of the Census agreed to reinstate the literacy question. Even then, instead of posing questions about actual skills, the census simply asked adults how many years of school they had attended. More than 5 percent of those the census reached replied that they had had less than a fifth grade education. For no known reason, the government assumed that four fifths of these people probably could read and, on this dangerous assumption, it was publicly announced that 99 percent of all American adults could read and write. These are the figures which the U.S. government passed on to the United Nations for the purposes of worldwide compilations and comparisons." You can read the rest of chapter 5 here, which further explains the methodology and how the CIA figures are propaganda rather than science:

http://eserver.org/courses/spring97/76100o/readings/kozol.ht...

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by yummyfajitas on Monday September 05, 2011 @01:06AM (#2961221)
As I suspected, they set a rather high bar for "proficient".

According to this study, a non-proficient person can: consult reference materials to figure out which foods contain a certain vitamin, calculate the cost of ordering supplies from a catalog, or figure out what they are permitted to eat before a medical test.

In India, we actually have a significant number of people who are functionally illiterate. Most people can't leave a note saying "please make sambhar" note for the cook.

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by Alex3917 on Monday September 05, 2011 @01:15AM (#2961240)
Regardless of how exactly you define the word 'proficient', the fact is that these people spend 13 years in government schools at a cost of ~$200,000 and at the end of it they're unable to read at a level that would allow them to vote intelligently or contribute in any meaningful way to the democratic process.

If people can only read well enough to be consumers but not producers then it's only so long before society collapses, regardless of whether or not they're getting their vitamins.

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by yummyfajitas on Monday September 05, 2011 @01:38AM (#2961280)
The democratic process is a red herring. As I pointed out elsewhere, if we really cared about improving the democratic signal/noise ratio, we'd just bar morons from voting.

As for society collapsing, I think you grossly underestimate the value low intelligence people can provide when suitably directed. Consider walmart - it's a vast command economy which employs about 1% of the US (mostly taken from the bottom percentiles) and has improved the standard of living for millions.

A bunch of morons couldn't create walmart themselves. But they can still create great value when directed by a small number of intelligent people.

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by CaptainZapp on Monday September 05, 2011 @04:00AM (#2961546)

  we'd just bar morons from voting.
They tried that in Thailand. Replace Morons with Rural citizens and they tried to do exactly that.

This lead not only to a total political gridlock for years, but to actual death and mayhem.

You can't have a semi democracy where the elite decides, who's eligible to vote. It's either all or nothing.

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by lucasjung on Monday September 05, 2011 @02:04PM (#2962918)
They also tried it in the American South as part of Jim Crow: "literacy" tests that were hard for anyone to pass, with grandfather clauses so that all of the illiterate whites could keep voting (in fact, that's where the term "grandfather clause" comes from).

The problem with the term "moron" is that it is too easily applied to mean, "people who I don't think should be allowed to vote, no matter how intelligent they might actually be."

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by yummyfajitas on Monday September 05, 2011 @09:44PM (#2963800)
Racists were also in favor of socialism, gun control, teaching evolution in school, reduced taxation, labor unions, and freshly baked apple pie.

The fact that racists favor a corrupted version of a certain policy does not imply that the policy is bad.

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by true_religion on Monday September 05, 2011 @07:10AM (#2961875)
> You can't have a semi democracy where the elite decides, who's eligible to vote.

Historically, that's just an oligarchy or plutocracy.

Heck even being governed by a "council of elders" is a semi-democracy if not all elders are approved by the council to join their ranks.

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by seagaia on Monday September 05, 2011 @02:12AM (#2961349)
I think you have a point with the voting. If only it was that easy in practice - there are so many moral and ethical issues when it comes to drawing a line for "intelligent enough to vote".

A standardized test would be hard to impose, since how does one measure someone's ability to make good judgments about something?

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by rbanffy on Tuesday September 06, 2011 @02:08AM (#2964372)
> we'd just bar morons from voting.

Then, the next step would be preventing them from having kids...

You know it's a very, very bad idea. Morons are part of the society and deserve to have their voices heard. Any democratically elected government mirrors the society it came from.

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by nandemo on Monday September 05, 2011 @02:02AM (#2961333)
I'm curious as to why the above comment is being downvoted. I'm aware that some people downvote for mere disagreement or dislike but I hope it's not that widespread yet.
Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by rat on Monday September 05, 2011 @03:48AM (#2961523)
Dictatorship of smart morons. Yay
Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by cma on Monday September 05, 2011 @02:12AM (#2961354)
When the government hires someone, the portion that person pays in tax goes back to the government, so the $200000 cost figure is misleading.
Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by hammerdr on Monday September 05, 2011 @12:52AM (#2961187)
> In other words, the majority of graduate students are incapable of fully understanding a newspaper

I think this indicates a serious problem with the study. While I'm sure there are exceptional cases where someone could graduate from a post-graduate program as functionally illiterate[1], every other non-exceptional case is able to function quite well in our society. You don't need to know every word in the newspaper (you can get those through contextual clues) or if there are 8 ounces in a cup or a pint (I'd Google it) in order to function in our society or to interact with other people writing the same language.

[1] Using the common sense definition found at wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_illiteracy

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by Alex3917 on Monday September 05, 2011 @01:10AM (#2961234)
I think you're right on the cup vs. pint type questions. But quantitative literacy is only one of the three types of literacy they are measuring, so it doesn't really change the overall picture much.
Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by pjscott on Monday September 05, 2011 @01:20AM (#2961248)
In case anybody wants to know exactly what the NAAL test measures, there are some example questions here:

http://nces.ed.gov/NAAL/sample_items.asp

They're setting the bar pretty low. Not so low you can't bear to look at it, but still, wow.