News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by csomar on Sunday September 04, 2011 @10:23PM (#2960915)
This is my opinion in education, and it tends to differ than the author one: You don't need to teach science in primary schools to have a science literate population. Teach them to read, only.

Why: Because reading is key. What I learnt on my own reading books in one year was more than what I was taught in all these primary years. They have helped, but even if I didn't take these classes that wouldn't be a roadblock.

How I envision a successful education:

1. Language is priority: Reading, writing and communicating. Dedicate long hours for reading and daily writing. This is better than science or math. I need to be able to read, and also communicate effectively with others (forums, chat...)

2. Math: Math is also important. Dedicate a good amount of hours for a solid math education.

3. Others: It includes science, geography, history... What does the average person need of information to be relatively literate? Give it that amount of information; only. The bare minimum so he can understand things like nuclear radiations, ADN, therapies...

And then? Let people decide. Science is not for everyone. There is a writer, designer, business analyst... They don't need science, but they are in need in the society. Let everyone decide what he wants to be. You allowed him to read and communicate effectively. Don't worry about what will happen next.

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by SamReidHughes on Sunday September 04, 2011 @10:41PM (#2960949)
Science education probably does a lot to change people's view of the world. After all, chemistry and biology teach people that they're made of chemicals and cells that, as far as we can tell, act deterministically (or randomly), or at least cells act autonomously. How is that less important than trigonometry?
Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by mkr-hn on Sunday September 04, 2011 @10:50PM (#2960964)
You don't need to spend 12 years in grade school to understand and appreciate those things.
Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by MarkPNeyer on Monday September 05, 2011 @02:00AM (#2961330)
deterministically or randomly?

neither of those could be farther from the truth.

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by bluedanieru on Monday September 05, 2011 @02:13AM (#2961358)
The universe isn't deterministic? You've solved this? Please share!
Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by thehotdon on Monday September 05, 2011 @03:44AM (#2961517)
There's a man in the clouds jiggling us around with puppet strings, obviously.

And the man in the clouds, well, I guess he's controlled by a mystic turtle in outer space...

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by bluedanieru on Monday September 05, 2011 @04:04AM (#2961554)
And you've discovered that determinism implies an omnipotent creator/deity?! Truly we are breaking ground here on HN that the best philosophers and scientists throughout history have grappled with for tens of thousands of lifetimes!
Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by MarkPNeyer on Monday September 05, 2011 @05:14AM (#2961668)
quantum mechanics is neither deterministic (due to quantum superposition) nor random (we can make predictions).

i don't see how this is controversial or silly.

Re:America is losing another generation to science illiteracy by ajuc on Monday September 05, 2011 @06:57AM (#2961846)
I don't know which meaning of random you have in mind, but we can make predictions about random "things".

If I understand correctly if we measure qubit that is in 10/90 superposition of 0 and 1, we have 0.1 and 0.9 chance of it becoming 0 and 1 respectively. We can predict, that it would probably be 1, but it is still random.

Or am I wrong?