Re:What Does It Mean for AI to Understand?
by Verdex on Thursday December 16, 2021 @02:42PM
(#29582844)
It's not a hierarchy, it's just a list. Structural isn't meaningfully better than anything else. It just "works" for different reasons.
Intuitive is often faster to react and faster to get off the ground and producing results. So in a fight intuition is probably going to be better. That being said, supposedly the boxing fight that the movie 'cinderella man' was based off of involved Braddock analyzing Baer's fighting style and figuring out some foot work that kept him from getting pummeled. There's no reason that structural, intuitive, and social understanding can't all work together to get a result.
Re:What Does It Mean for AI to Understand?
by prometheus76 on Thursday December 16, 2021 @02:44PM
(#29582878)
I misunderstood what you said as a hierarchy because of how you worded your last paragraph, but I would agree with you that synthesizing the different types of knowledge is the best way to interact with the world.
Here's another way of putting what I'm saying: when we want to learn about a tree, in the West, our first inclination is to cut it down, categorize/classify the parts, and count the rings. We think we know what a "tree" is at that point. In the East (and I'm learning this perspective from Eastern Orthodox Christianity), if you want to learn about a tree, you plant one. Maybe more than one. Nurture it. Prune it. Fertilize it. Watch it grow. Watch it change with the seasons. Build a treehouse in it for your kids. Watch your daughter get married in the shade of the tree. In other words, instead of dissecting something (which kills the thing itself) in order to categorically "understand" something propositionally, in the East, they focus on having a relationship with something in order to understand it.