News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by sliverstorm on Saturday September 03, 2011 @04:14PM (#2958030)
As far as food & overeating/unhealthy foods- I've learned you don't necessarily need self-control. You can stop caring instead. That's how I wound up after going hungry for months, and got used to it.

It's frighteningly effective. Right now, the last meal I remember was about 20 hours ago, and the last meal before that was another 20-24 ago. My stomach is aching, but it doesn't bother me.

Of course, this is not without problems. It basically means I have to consciously remember to feed myself enough to stay healthy. You could say I am now approaching the problem from the opposite direction.

Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by dualogy on Saturday September 03, 2011 @07:38PM (#2958398)
Starving for hours and ignoring your body's warning signals? Whatever happened to "don't eat less, eat better" -- "don't reduce quantity, increase quality"?

If you enjoy eating and don't enjoy the sounds made by a hungry stomach... you can munch down as many of those fresh veggies as you like and will feel all the better for it, while not gaining a pound. Something to consider. Not the same for fruits as they do contain sugars... but veggies, the sky is the limit!

Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by beagle3 on Sunday September 04, 2011 @11:16AM (#2959509)
I've gone between 10 and 30 days without eating several times before. It really is good for you if you are relatively healthy to start with.

The first two days are key; You will go crazy if you are unprepared. Remedies for the craziness are drinking lemon water (freshly squeezed lemon in water, possibly with some sweetener but you'll need much less if it is unsweetened), and doing 5-10 minutes of exercise every time you feel the need to eat. Another option is to start when you've lost appetite due to some illness or mild depression - that makes the first two days pass easily.

And then something magical happens - you stop caring about food. For a long time. The smells don't matter, the sight doesn't matter. (Although if you force yourself to eat, it will stat mattering again in a few hours).

A few days or weeks later, you will feel hunger - and realize it is the first time ever you have felt hunger -- everything you felt before you _thought_ was hunger, was just plain appetite. hunger feels different, and it also cannot be suppressed by reading an interesting article or playing a video game.

There are also health benefits, but I highly recommend it just for the psychological experience.

Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by gwern on Sunday September 04, 2011 @12:15PM (#2959628)
I've only done this for 5 days max, but your experience tracks with mine. It's fascinating from a psychological point of view; I'd agree it's one of those things one ought to try at least once, like skydiving (which comes to mind since I skydived for the first time yesterday).
Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by sliverstorm on Saturday September 03, 2011 @08:14PM (#2958446)
I'm not saying it's the right way to do things. I don't think that starving myself is GOOD. A hungry stomach just doesn't bother me anymore, so I have to proactively think about food. That may seem nonsensical to you if you are still deeply in touch with your sense of hunger, but take me at my word.

I didn't choose for it to be this way, I just didn't have much money for a while.

Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by olliesaunders on Saturday September 03, 2011 @08:50PM (#2958492)
You didn’t have enough money to eat? That must have been tough. I hope things are better for you now.
Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by sliverstorm on Saturday September 03, 2011 @09:03PM (#2958514)
At least, not enough to eat properly. It's ok though- that was years ago, and I learned a lot from those times.
Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by guelo on Sunday September 04, 2011 @05:13AM (#2959116)
Actually it might be the right way to do things. Scientists have found that the most effective way to make monkeys live longer is by starving them their whole lives.
Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by dualogy on Saturday September 10, 2011 @09:46PM (#2982979)
It wasn't scientists who tried that on humans (I hope) but unlike monkeys, famines and malnutrition seems to never have had similarly good results in humans. Snark aside, that's interesting but I wonder what degree of starving produces such good effects -- clearly, no-food kills us so learning just how much or how little to "starve" is healthiest would help.
Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by Natsu on Sunday September 04, 2011 @04:09PM (#2960224)
> A hungry stomach just doesn't bother me anymore, so I have to proactively think about food.

I know what you mean. I drive people crazy when they realize that I can work through lunch and simply not miss it.

Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by Estragon on Sunday September 04, 2011 @05:14AM (#2959120)
This is actually a common eating regime for Buddhist mmonks, who have been doing it by the millions for millenia, because the Buddha is believed to have eaten that way, and recommended it as conducive to health and longevity. I've done it a few times for about a month at a stretch each time. It is quite feasible.
Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by sunchild on Monday September 05, 2011 @02:25PM (#2962959)
At this point, the "science" of nutrition is so muddled and tainted by commercial interests as to be essentially without any credibility whatsoever. Pop science articles like the the OP NYT.com link only add to the mess – using absurd metaphors like muscle fatigue for willpower, and talking about self-control as an exhaustible "resource" based on some no-doubt extremely qualitative and subjective study.

Health information in western cultures is very low signal to noise.

Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by boredguy8 on Saturday September 03, 2011 @04:24PM (#2958045)
"Easier said than done, I know, but the thing I find helps most people is to understand that you can't refrain from doing something you like. You can, however, change the person you are into the kind of person who doesn't even like that stuff. Sugar Smacks still taste the same as they did under Carter, but I don't know anybody who still eats them. Do the same for soda."
Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by kragen on Sunday September 04, 2011 @05:24PM (#2960359)
For the other readers who are wondering what Sugar Smacks are, Wikipedia tells me they've been called Honey Smacks for a long time now, with a brief period of being just Smacks. I don't think I've ever had them. My parents were not big fans of sugary breakfasts, and Honey Smacks are apparently the sugariest of the sugary, over 50% sugar by weight!
Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by tomlin on Sunday September 04, 2011 @02:34PM (#2959995)
While your timespans are perhaps a little long, I adopted a similar approach, which allowed me to lose 70lbs.

Basically, I stopped looking forward to food and began seeing food as fuel. Like having to re-fuel your car, eating sometimes got to be more of a chore than a delight.

Our society looks at food as an indulgence, when perhaps it would be better to look at it as an energy source.

The Western mantra of "eat the things you love and look great doing it!" is probably cognitive dissonance at its best, not helping society at all.

Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by zcid on Sunday September 04, 2011 @03:48PM (#2960180)
This is very similar to what I tell people asking me about weight loss: "You can't have an emotional attachment to food." I can't remember where I first heard that, but I think it states the idea perfectly.
Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by revorad on Sunday September 04, 2011 @07:43AM (#2959247)
That sounds scary. How does that affect your energy levels? Are you able to do much work, physical or involving hard thinking? I find that on days I'm working on hard programming problems, I feel hungrier.
Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by rkalla on Saturday September 03, 2011 @04:22PM (#2958042)
Interesting approach. A lot of people would say "that doesn't fix anything because you replaced one problem with another!" but I would say it does help; it gives you another perspective on the same problem.

Eventually you'll find the middle ground that works for you, but I applaud you providing at least another unconventional alternative to tackling food-control.

Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by tomjen3 on Saturday September 03, 2011 @07:56PM (#2958421)
That's a super interesting idea, but how do you stop caring in the first place?
Re:The Sugary Secret of Self-Control by sgns on Tuesday September 06, 2011 @03:10AM (#2964504)
I've done a little bit of fasting (I'm actually breaking a fast right now), it really is as simple as that: you simply start seeing whatever it is as not important. Sliverstorm, beagle3 and gwern are exactly right I think.

What you wanted - food - was just a result of you thinking you wanted it. And that was mostly just a result of associating it with the thought of 'need'. But our bodies are apparently made to not bother us needlessly - it's not the body that's bothering us.

When you fast, rather, you go through the whole range of conditioned responses YOU have created to food. But you don't fight them, instead you get to just kind of say 'yeah, that's an interesting thing I've created' and go on with what you're doing. But once you know they are just that, nothing is stopping you. It's a little bit like meditation, where when you notice a thought, you'll simply label it a thought, and its power goes away.

And since you 'know' you will take great care of your body, now and whenever you break the fast (and please do that, follow the instructions, and break it gently, like a part of fasting, rather than straight back to old habits - your pancreas & co will thank you...), there's no crisis thinking or anxiety to it. Rather you get to be alone with your body and your thoughts.

I like it, because it is actually sort of easier to focus when there's just my body doing its things, vs the body with a lot of food it's having to digest, and blood sugar levels going up and down all over the place.

You get to really want something else instead, rather than associating/replacing all sorts of wants with food, if that's what you've done before. It's like realizing those wants are yours and owning them as that, rather than being owned by them when you think it is 'needs'.

Eating regularly is just a routine - probably a good one if it is done right - but there's so much extra luggage, so much extra use, that we put on top.

We really have a lot more power than that. It's not us against the body, it's us thanks to the body. Not thanks to the food - we eat much more than we 'need'.