News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pandalized: Sites Negatively Impacted by Google's Panda U... by Rusky on Saturday September 03, 2011 @11:59AM (#2957487)
I love how chacha.com is the first one on that list. Of course they're doing worse, that was the entire point. Nobody wants to find results from some random person spewing out whatever answers they feel like.
Re:Pandalized: Sites Negatively Impacted by Google's Panda U... by troutwine on Saturday September 03, 2011 @12:52PM (#2957589)
I never happened across chacha.com results in any of my searches. I'm unsure of it's purpose, based on its website. What does/did it do?
Re:Pandalized: Sites Negatively Impacted by Google's Panda U... by dangrossman on Saturday September 03, 2011 @01:22PM (#2957666)
Human-powered Q&A/search. You ask a question, a human gets paid a pittance to answer it. They are focused on mobile now (text a question, get a text back with an answer). Sometimes their answers show up in search results (I've encountered them), and they're usually just a few words and not very useful.
Re:Pandalized: Sites Negatively Impacted by Google's Panda U... by codexon on Saturday September 03, 2011 @03:06PM (#2957895)
Just to play devil's advocate, how is this different from stackoverflow or quora? (Maybe they were pandalized too?)
Re:Pandalized: Sites Negatively Impacted by Google's Panda U... by antimarketing on Saturday September 03, 2011 @05:27PM (#2958153)
Good question, I played the Devil's Advocate inside my mind. Here is what I get as return / output: All the traditional elements of marketing are different:

a) Is the target market specific?

Yes for q. & s., no for c.c.

b) Is the target market pro. / high-end users with high sense of fidelity to the topic / site / brand or casual consumers?

Yes for q. & s., no for c.c.

c) Does the target audience return to said sites regularly, participate in a community (with hierarchies, badges, comments and replies etc..)?

Yes for q. & s., no for c.c.

d) Do the specific topics discussed get relevant links from blogs, tuts sites etc.. from similiar fields

Yes for q. & s., no for c.c.

This is simply the tip of the iceberg.

Re:Pandalized: Sites Negatively Impacted by Google's Panda U... by codexon on Saturday September 03, 2011 @07:57PM (#2958422)
a) How are they market specific? Stackexchange tries to target every possible topic that is popular, while Quora targets every possible topic.

b) See above

c) Is there any evidence for this? ChaCha also has comments. The badges seem to be a gimmick to promote addictiveness, the novelty of which seems be gradually wearing off. Does a Google searcher care about the addictiveness of a website, or do they care about finding what they want?

d) The majority of topics are not discussed from relevant links from blogs and tutorial sites. In fact, many of the answers from Stackoverflow are taken from blogs and other websites.

I don't even see the tip of an iceberg.

Re:Pandalized: Sites Negatively Impacted by Google's Panda U... by Rusky on Sunday September 04, 2011 @04:56PM (#2960315)
a & b) StackOverflow itself is very specific and is probably a better example of having a specific market with pro users.

c) ChaCha may have comments but, like in (b), who participates in them? Knowledgeable members of the field? Definitely not for ChaCha.