Re:Uncomfortable Truths in Software Engineering
by MathCodeLove on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:08PM
(#29570282)
That's fair. I do believe that in an ideal world, everyone's barrier to entry into any profession would be equal removing all factors except merit. While that's obviously not possible, I do think it's worthwhile to work towards that. I also think that it can be worthwhile to make it known to women that tech and other career paths are viable and not out of reach for them - as I'm sure some women just have never considered it just as I have never seriously considered becoming a nurse. However, I think that's where it should stop. Make it known that it's an option, make it so that if they choose to pursue it that it's no more difficult for them than it would be if they were a man, and then let it be.
Anything more and it becomes the individual(s) behind the movement projecting their desires onto others and is no different that the societal molding that's taken place for the past several decades.
Re:Uncomfortable Truths in Software Engineering
by JuliusBranson on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:34PM
(#29571290)
I'm only interested in why you believe what you believe. How smart are you? What do you value most? How truth-oriented is your epistemology?
I'm glad you don't discriminate (nothing "reverse" about it) against men, but many do, and since [your views are wrong](https://www.amazon.com/Essential-Difference-Female-Brains-Au...) it's tantamount to sex-based theft and redistribution.
Re:Uncomfortable Truths in Software Engineering
by curtainsforus on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:19PM
(#29570387)
If you're wrong, surely you'll have materially harmed some people by encouraging them to do something they don't like?
Re:Uncomfortable Truths in Software Engineering
by evouga on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:04PM
(#29570920)
The unstated major premise here is that software engineering work is valuable/fulfilling/high-status, while other work is not---so that pushing someone naturally suited to software engineering away causes harm, while pushing people more naturally suited to a different field into software engineering causes less harm.
I don't think your premise is wrong, but I think it does explain why computer science is particularly focused on broadening participation, compared to other disciplines like nursing, teaching, etc. Computer science is current (for better or ill) a golden ticket to economic mobility.
Given how slanted these stakes are and how many times society as a whole has underestimated women as a whole, I think the right answer here is to err on the side of trying to get women and other underrepresented minorities interested into tech.
[0] bear in mind what I said about the particular way I’m putting my belief into practice and that I do not believe in “reverse discrimination” to even the scales.