News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stanford Accelerated Intelligent Neuromodulation Therapy ... by cupcake-unicorn on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:44AM (#29563439)
Why is the media doing this with old depression treatments that have been around for ages? First it was the deep brain stimulation article, now this? rTMS technology has been around since 2008. The picture they are using is the same magnetic figure 8 coil that they used on the first devices and not even the newer technology using the Brainsway or deep TMS device.

This article is incredibly frustrating. This is NOT new technology. It is a different modality called theta burst which they didn't even mention the name of in the article. The benefit of using theta burst is that you can do TMS courses much faster. This is a major benefit but the technology is still the same. If you didn't have remission with the prolonged rTMS course theta burst is not a magic bullet. The benefit is that it's easier to do bilateral treatment and speed up the treatment quite a bit. Normally you have to come in every business day for a few months for 20 mins at a time.

It really sucks to have "lay people" in my life email me these articles like this is some new breakthrough. The articles often come out prior to FDA approval but these modalities have been around for 10+ years prior and I always knew about them with someone with treatment resistant depression. Remember, off label treatments are a thing, and theta burst was available well before this study came out.

I'm currently undergoing deep TMS treatment with the Brainsway device on my left hemisphere and they were able to boost the treatment by adding the theta burst with the figure 8 coil like in the picture to do my right hemisphere to improve chances of remission. It is a good trick and it boosts your chances of remission because it's faster and easier to do bilateral but as I said there is nothing magical about theta burst other than it's a very fast treatment. Those who didn't have remission on long courses of TMS before unilaterally probably aren't going to magically have remission on this. What we might end up seeing is some kind of threshhold that wasn't achievable in the past, say that some people could reach remission but it's not feasible to come into the office every day for 6 months.

Anyway TMS is great and should be used more but I just hate these dumb articles. Especially since it's touting this as some magical new technology. No way. And we're still a long way from TMS being prescribed in general cases - less side effects than meds but insurance wise you have to trial and fail several meds before it's covered. Even SSRIs which are given out like candy can have severe side effects like GI bleeding. TMS is very, very safe with few side effects. For me it was just discomfort during the treatment but not after.

Also just got to say this quote summed up how ridiculous the article was for me: "“This study is hopefully just the tip of the iceberg,” said Siddiqi. “I think we're finally on the verge of a paradigm shift in how we think about psychiatric treatment, where we'll supplement the conventional chemical imbalance and psychological conflict models with a new brain circuit model.” In other words, psychiatrists will use electricity instead of talk therapy and drugs to treat mental health disorders." No reason to make rTMS sound like some Frankenstein tech and no, rTMS will not be used "instead of talk therapy and drugs".

TBH a little disappointed at hacker news, next time link to the study! I would love to see articles on NEW treatments for depression. Spoiler alert..there really haven't been any for a long time now. Just me too drugs and this is a bit of a me too tech as well.

Re:Stanford Accelerated Intelligent Neuromodulation Therapy ... by TulliusCicero on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:13PM (#29568774)
Here's an article that makes it clearer that the big change is the speedup: https://www.kqed.org/news/11898991/it-saved-my-life-depressi...

> TBH a little disappointed at hacker news, next time link to the study! I would love to see articles on NEW treatments for depression. Spoiler alert..there really haven't been any for a long time now. Just me too drugs and this is a bit of a me too tech as well.

No sorry, this is silly. For one thing, because speeding up a treatment from taking 6 weeks to 5 days is still pretty huge. And also because what inevitably happens is:

> New experimental treatment with potential discovered

HN: "yawn, most of these never pan out, let me know when they have completed studies"

> New treatment study shows amazing results

HN: "Okay, but nobody can get it yet, right? It's gonna be years"

> New treatment widely available

HN: *crickets*

or

HN: "So what? It's not a NEW treatment, we've known about this for YEARS now"

No matter what, you have people dismissing some new thing, because either it's too new to know for sure whether it works, or it's not new enough to be interesting. Your comment is a perfect example of that, as it's new enough to where most people probably have never heard of this treatment, but you're already dismissing it as too old and boring.

Re:Stanford Accelerated Intelligent Neuromodulation Therapy ... by cupcake-unicorn on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:31PM (#29570528)
I think you missed the point of my comment and fair enough because I was ranting :)

TMS is a GREAT technology. More people should use it, and it should be considered first line treatment over meds. These machines should be in inpatient psych wards. TMS will inevitably help people. I'm not contesting any of that and this is a good thing.

HOWEVER - this is a small study and I'm willing to bet they didn't include people who had failed previous rounds of TMS (or maybe even people who had failed ECT) for a reason. Because it's still the same technology. I'm pretty sure that the remission rate for this will top off around 30%, perhaps a bit more, when more studies have been done and we're looking and real world treatment resistant patients, which is about what we see with TMS (and ketamine for that matter) already.

The point I'm trying to make is that treatment resistant depression is very common and debilitating. If someone is very treatment resistant, they will have tried TMS in the course of their treatment, as I did in 2012, when it was first released. I'm not sure how common this is but in my state Medicaid covers the cost of a course of TMS.

We need new treatment modalities, not because TMS or existing treatments are "boring or "old news", but because treatment resistant depression is a serious issue and we have very limited tools as of yet to help people who aren't responding to these end of the line treatments.

I'm also wary of how TMS is handled in clinics. It can be a bit cult like in some places (doctors overprescribing, overpromising, shrugging off side effects in populations that shouldn't be getting it like bipolar). The quote at the end of the article scares me too. I've noticed the more widespread and accepted a treatment becomes, the more stigmatized and impossible it is as a patient to get help. BUT WHAT PROZAC DIDN'T WORK FOR YOU?? BUT HUHH, CBT DIDN'T WORK FOR YOU?

15 years in, I still get doctors trying to get me back on an SSRI and try behavioralism on me. There are people who are very treatment resistant, and we need to understand this isn't a cure all. The more of a "fad" something becomes the more screwed you are in the medical system looking for help when it legitimately didn't work for you, even though we know even from this paper it's not a 100% remission rate. That's my perspective and lived experience that I'm trying to bring to this discussion.

TMS is great, and it's great it's being adopted more. But I'm wary of what that means for people who really need help and have failed TMS and other treatments and need and new modalities like me. I can hold both perspectives.

Re:Stanford Accelerated Intelligent Neuromodulation Therapy ... by TulliusCicero on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:34PM (#29570582)
> If someone is very treatment resistant, they will have tried TMS in the course of their treatment,

[citation needed]

A dear relative of mine has depression that medication has only sort of worked for, and they'd never even heard of this treatment before I just linked them to it. I think you're drastically overestimating how aware people are of more recent treatments. Not everyone is hyperconnected to new medical developments.

Plus, making a fairly effective treatment work in five days vs six weeks is still a huge deal. And that helps answers your question of, "Why is the media doing this with old depression treatments that have been around for ages?" Because it's not actually that old, a lot of people don't know about it, AND it's a big step forward for the practicality of that treatment.

Re:Stanford Accelerated Intelligent Neuromodulation Therapy ... by cupcake-unicorn on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:40PM (#29570645)
I'm not saying it's not a huge deal.

I wouldn't consider your relative necessarily treatment resistant. I'm talking about those of us who have been left behind. In my case, that's 15+ plus of over 30 medication trials (following the STAR-D algorithm as well), failed bilateral ECT, TMS, ketamine IV, trigeminal nerve stimulation, and more. I'm on disability for the depression.

I'm not trying to invalidate your relative's situation but there are also people who have been stuck in the system for years like me and we need NEW OPTIONS. As I said, both things can be true. TMS being made faster is good, but we can't stop there, and that's my perspective on the article with someone with my lived experience. Not everyone knows someone this treatment resistant so I'm offering my unique experience about it. Your relative's experience and anyone who has tried a few meds or even hasn't and wants to try TMS is valid and I'm happy this exists. What I'm saying is that for the smaller population like me who has already been left behind this isn't going to help that much.

Re:Stanford Accelerated Intelligent Neuromodulation Therapy ... by disabled on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:12PM (#29568750)
> Even SSRIs which are given out like candy can have severe side effects like GI bleeding.

SSRIs and SNRIs can cause akathisia. It happened to me, and it was by far the worst thing that happened to me ever in my life. I went through 6 months of nonstop hell with akathisia, and it was the worst 6 months of my life. Trust me, if you have severe akathisia, it is worse than death.

This is somebody who has akathisia from taking Effexor (an SNRI): https://youtu.be/W_iiy8ISvdY

This is a public service announcement from an akathisia advocacy group (known as Akathisia Alliance) about akathisia: https://youtu.be/VgvhAilA070

Here is an article from a mother whose son developed akathisia from taking an SSRI for about a week. (My story has a lot of common denominators to this one): https://www.madinamerica.com/2021/06/boy-interrupted-a-story...

Re:Stanford Accelerated Intelligent Neuromodulation Therapy ... by cupcake-unicorn on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:35PM (#29570588)
SSRIs are awful. I still have doctors trying to throw them at me after 15+ years of treatment resistant depression. It's honestly delusional. MAOIs actually have less drug/drug interactions and less systemic reactions if used responsibly. If another drug had the same dangers SSRIs had I don't think doctors would be overprescribing it as much but by definition people who are going in to get Prozac, we can easily tell them everything's in their head and blame anything that happens on their disorder.

SSRIs also INCREASE the risk of suicide and a trial with healthy people without history of behavioral health issues on Prozac ended in some of the patients dying this way. This has been a huge cover up and I'm not sure if these meds got the black box warning about this. It's easy to say "ohh these patients would have done that anyway, they're depressed" but that's not what the data shows...

Re:Stanford Accelerated Intelligent Neuromodulation Therapy ... by touisteur on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:56PM (#29570814)
I don't know about a cover, but the notice at least in France for venlafaxine (Effexor) are quite clear about the increase of suicidal ideation in the first week(s), during which neurotransmitters rebalance. I was briefed by my doc and it still was quite the experience, trying the whole day to keep myself from jumping in front of trains, cars, or from bridges, windows, cars... Like 'WTF is happening to me'.

I also had very strange differences in mood or tolerance between brands of generics, that I'd never had before with any med. I'd go from OK to crap in 2 weeks and my wife would link it to prescription renewal and pharmacist giving me whatever brand. I used to think it didn't matter...

Oh and venlafaxine is a bitch to taper out. Constant vertigo, nausea, ringing and tingling, migraines and the fun panic attacks...

If we can find better, please please please keep researching.

Re:Stanford Accelerated Intelligent Neuromodulation Therapy ... by cupcake-unicorn on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:57PM (#29572109)
> If we can find better, please please please keep researching.

Agreed. The current push and research around ketamine/psilocybin is promising but can't come fast enough. Other than the ketamine spray which is still very hard to get and needs to be taken in office there have been no novel depression treatments for decades really.