News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HP 15c Scientific Calculator to be Re-issued by mahmud on Friday September 02, 2011 @10:19PM (#2956283)
Science left the limitations of the pocket calculator behind, ages ago. Any field of analytic research, be it science, engineering, finance, etc. the values you manipulate on a day to day basis are no longer scalars, but tend to be matrices, often very large ones.

TI got this part right, sort of: the TI calculators while clumsy for data entry have 2D screens and make apparent the various interpretations of mathematical objects, as equations, matrices, and graphs.

Re:HP 15c Scientific Calculator to be Re-issued by runningdogx on Saturday September 03, 2011 @12:19AM (#2956473)
Really? I think the n-spires are going in the wrong direction for post-academic users, trying to approach the input (full alphabetic keyboard) and UI of a computer on a severely size-constrained piece of hardware, rather than focusing on what I think stand-alone calculators should be about: an easily manipulated tool for back of the envelope calculations and first-try graphing of equations. By allowing easily accessible alphabetic entry, it makes typing in complex equations easier, but anyone who is not constrained by academic requirements will be using matlab/R/mathematica/etc. for that, rather than trying to type using a small non-qwerty keypad, and getting results on a too-small screen.

I understand the logic of something like the n-spire for academics (though I'd prefer an HP 50g): get a piece of hardware that can do enough math for testing purposes, but limited in usability and/or IO, to hopefully reduce cheating, and have students use it in class and for homework so they are familiar with it by the time they have to use it on a test. However, it's sad that an entire industry (calculator hardware) requires poor and time-wasting data and formula entry characteristics (mostly based on required form factor) simply to avoid having students cheat on tests (both in-classroom and standardized tests).

How much time and effort would be saved if students could use smartphones or tablets with a customizable calculator UI? Calculators' limited screen size, inflexible input, and limited market size compared to smartphones/tablets ensures they will remain hamstrung.

And TI still hasn't gotten it through their heads that RPN should be a basic supported calculator mode, not left to a 3rd party to implement as an optional program.

Disclosure: I grew up with a TI 30+, 34, 68, 81, 83+, and then a HP 48gx -- which got me through most of HS and college, hence my strong preference for RPN. My HP48 broke (screen damage, no fault of HP's) and I never replaced it. I've used a calculator probably a single-digit number of times since then.

Re:HP 15c Scientific Calculator to be Re-issued by sliverstorm on Saturday September 03, 2011 @12:30AM (#2956489)
Pocket or table calculators can still be useful for quick calculations. Of course you won't use a 15C for any seriously heavy lifting anymore- you have MATLAB and Mathematica for that now- but M & M are poor tools for spur-of-the-moment computation.
Re:HP 15c Scientific Calculator to be Re-issued by w1ntermute on Saturday September 03, 2011 @01:11AM (#2956550)
> but M & M are poor tools for spur-of-the-moment computation.

I don't really see how this is the case. The only advantage of a stand-alone calculator, now that I'm done with standardized test taking, is its portability. And when most of my work takes place in front of a computer anyway, I might as well just keep a copy of Mathematica humming so I can use it as soon as I need to do a calculation.

In fact, having to pull out a standalone calculator, turn it on, and adjust my frame of mind from "computer" to "standalone calculator" would probably be very bad for spur-of-the-moment calculations.

Re:HP 15c Scientific Calculator to be Re-issued by sliverstorm on Saturday September 03, 2011 @02:03AM (#2956633)
Well, I was thinking of more when I'm talking over my whiteboard with a co-worker, or something like that. Also, M & M are not light on the footprint... I don't especially enjoy leaving them open.
Re:HP 15c Scientific Calculator to be Re-issued by w1ntermute on Saturday September 03, 2011 @02:21PM (#2957793)
That's definitely true when you're in a conference room working over something, though nowadays I'm just using a scientific calculator app on my Android phone instead, since that means I've got one less device to keep track of.