News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Webb placed on top of Ariane 5 by giantrobot on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @01:55PM (#29555723)
> Why wasn't 5 Hubble telescopes launched? The marginal cost for the other 4 must have been vastly smaller than the first.

Economies of scale only apply at, well, scale. Five Hubbles would cost 5x one Hubble to construct. There's very little in the way of savings because most parts are custom fabricated. The parts need to be tested, integrated, then tested after integration. The testing and verification of each subsystem takes the same number of person-hours. So testing 5x the systems requires 5x the time.

You can't just accept a high failure rate of something the size of Hubble just because you've built five of them. If you launched a Hubble and it failed in some Loss of Vehicle fashion after inserted into orbit you've got a big uncontrollable mass of telescope flying around the Earth.

Even if we still had the Space Shuttle (or a fantasy version of the SpaceX Starship) flying an uncontrollable Hubble couldn't necessarily be retrieved. If it wasn't accepting commands and was spinning on some axis it would be too dangerous to approach with another vehicle. Even an unmanned vehicle couldn't necessarily approach it without a collision that causes even more problems. See the recent idiotic Russian ASAT test for an object lesson in what could happen.

This is all to say you don't want some large satellite in a long lived orbit to fail. So there's no savings on testing and verification. Even though at launch Hubble's mirror had problems the satellite itself was fully under control and operable.

Something like Starlink is very different. All the satellites in a given block are functionally identical and fungible. If one fails it's easily replaced by another. They also deploy to a low unstable orbit. If a Starlink satellite fails and is uncontrollable it will de orbit by itself quickly. They must be functional to enable the onboard engines that get them to a stable intended orbit. A Starlink satellite then needs far less testing and verification than a Hubble or JWST, not that they can be poor quality but they don't need to function Or Else Bad Things.

Re:Webb placed on top of Ariane 5 by mbfg on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @01:59PM (#29555797)
Is that really true? I'm guessing a big part of the cost is figuring out how to actually invent stuff needed for the project. That knowledge is now known. That cost is now 0.
Re:Webb placed on top of Ariane 5 by bumby on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @02:05PM (#29555882)
>There's very little in the way of savings because most parts are custom fabricated. The parts need to be tested, integrated, then tested after integration.

To piggy back on the the GP's point, the fabrication research is only one small cost center. Quality control costs much more in aerospace than many people realize. The reason why a bolt may cost $150 is because it has to be tracked, material coupons kept/tracked/tested, held in bonded storage etc. and not because we had to figure out how to make a bolt. Those costs don't come down as much with scale as, say, raw material.

If it were all about knowledge costs, many designs today would be dramatically cheaper because many use technology (and even refurbished rockets) from 50 years ago.

Re:Webb placed on top of Ariane 5 by giantrobot on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @03:26PM (#29557093)
> I'm guessing a big part of the cost is figuring out how to actually invent stuff needed for the project.

We're talking about marginal costs, not development costs. So the cost to invent a component is already out of the equation. The high production cost of something like Hubble comes from testing and validation more than materials or fabrication.

The failure modes for something big in space can be extremely dangerous. Even a tiny "cheap" cubesat requires a lot of relatively expensive testing so there's a reasonable assurance it won't fail in some catastrophic fashion and destroy the entire rocket.

Testing space hardware is additionally difficult because you can only just approximate the hardware's operating environment on the ground. Space hardware also can't be easily repaired or repaired at all once launched. So you've got to test actual flight hardware and if it fails possibly rebuild it from scratch testing and validating the entire way.

Developing space hardware and high precision science instruments is expensive and difficult. But it's just a small portion of the overall mission cost for something like Hubble or JWST.

Re:Webb placed on top of Ariane 5 by mbfg on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @06:09PM (#29559423)
I defer to your knowledge, i'm not trying to be a jerk. But Hubble took like 30 years? or so to develop and build? How long would a second Hubble take? I'd have to imagine it's less than 5 years, no? That has to be a huge cost savings. The testing process would have to be more streamlined or efficient, i would think. You have a much better understanding of failure modes.
Re:Webb placed on top of Ariane 5 by giantrobot on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @11:26PM (#29562083)
The Hubble took a little over ten years to build and develop. It's launch was postponed to 1990 because of the Challenger disaster.

> The testing process would have to be more streamlined or efficient, i would think.

Why do you automatically assume testing for a complicated and delicate machine is inefficient or not streamlined? That's a pretty bold assumption with zero evidence.

Understanding failure modes doesn't help test and validate something any faster. There's a finite number of hours in a day and components need some proscribed amount of testing.

Re:Webb placed on top of Ariane 5 by Hextinium on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:30AM (#29562447)
Hubble took ~12 years from initial funding to launch with the challenger disaster postponing it 4 years out of that. Additionally if the decision was made to use traditional mirror techniques the Hubble was predicted to launch in 5 years already, instead of the difficulty they found with the alternative method but they didn't know that at the outset.
Re:Webb placed on top of Ariane 5 by 7952 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:05AM (#29563217)
You will encounter different bias the second time around. Although maybe this kind of stuff is less common in space industry. People could want to correct the mistakes of the first time. Spend time optimising things and taking more time. And people could take learned knowledge for granted and assume success was based on that.
Re:Webb placed on top of Ariane 5 by Quenty on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @02:07PM (#29555899)
Just because the knowledge exists in the world doesn’t mean that you know it. Consolidating knowledge is a non-trivial exercise.
Re:Webb placed on top of Ariane 5 by XorNot on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @09:26PM (#29561305)
The US absolutely could've built 5 Hubbles - because it did, they just don't look at Space - they look at Earth. The Hubble is basically a KH-11 spy sat chassis. NASA was given a gentle suggestion that if the optics package was a particular size, there was definitely a company in the US which could polish lens and mirror packages of exactly that size.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KH-11_KENNEN

Re:Webb placed on top of Ariane 5 by jinto36 on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @06:18PM (#29559513)
If they had built five Hubbles that each had defective mirrors and all of them needed a shuttle visit to correct the issues and make them usable...