Re:Log4j: Between a rock and a hard place
by pron on Monday December 13, 2021 @01:52PM
(#29542926)
Right, but the command-line is intentional: it is intended to make the application aware of potential maintenance and/or security issues, and setAccessible is really a potential maintenance and/or security issue. The only argument against it would be the desire to allow libraries to impose such risks on applications without the application knowing about it. I understand why some library authors would not like their users to know their libraries pose such a risk, but obviously the applications should take precedence.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Log4j: Between a rock and a hard place
by josephcsible on Monday December 13, 2021 @05:27PM
(#29545501)
My issue isn't that it needs a command line parameter. It's that you need to create a whitelist that enumerates everything that anything is going to use individually. I'd be fine with modules if --add-opens had a "let this module reflectively access everything" wildcard, or if --illegal-access=permit were never removed.
But that wouldn't express what the potential issue is. You want to know that internal changes in which modules could break you, and/or in what way you're expanding the security attack surface area. Such a library needs to tell you what "bad" things it does and give you a list of modules whose encapsulation in breaks open that you could put on the command line.