News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Managed by Bots: surveillance of gig economy workers by pessimizer on Monday December 13, 2021 @12:56PM (#29542189)
> But I also think that HN overestimates the ability for single engineers to upend the goals of an entire organization. In the real world, if a company wants to automate anything and they’re paying well, there will be a line of engineers out the door applying to get it done.

There's a similar effect in journalism, where the loudest voices saying that individual journalists have the duty and ability to maintain the integrity of journalism are often other journalists.

It's a survivorship thing - the journalists/engineers who stay employed as such are the ones who probably honestly believe in the same things that their employers do, or at least have an output high enough in the things that their employers won't feel the need to heavily edit or nix entirely to have nearly the same effect. It creates an illusion of control.

But ultimately the author of anything is the person whose yeses and nos cannot be overridden, and that's the boss.

> In practice, companies know very well that automated customer support and similar solutions aren’t comparable to having a well-paid, highly-trained person pick up the phone.

And even if it's not particularly expensive in itself, the fact is that having bad customer service reduces complaints. Having anonymous/automated customer service even reduces complaints about customer service - because there's no way to identify or isolate a particular bad customer service experience, like a name. Avoiding the complaints probably creates so much savings that it would be worth automating customer service even if that cost more than having good, live customer service.

We do the same thing in means testing/bureaucracy in welfare/social services. The more difficult or confusing it is to prove one's qualification, the fewer qualified people will have to be serviced. In that case, spending more on "customer service" (i.e. adding more steps) ultimately reduces costs.

> There are a few people who will proudly pay more for the better CS, but they are a tiny minority.

There are also very few ways to know that the customer service on a product will be terrible before you need it. People aren't actively picking bad customer service any more than people choose to watch bad movies at theaters. It's something you find out about after you've already bought in.

There are no comments on this comment yet.