News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by hn_throwaway_99 on Sunday December 12, 2021 @11:21PM (#29536564)
I read about another study relatively recently (maybe it was HN? Not sure.) that talked about some of the fundamental flaws when looking at these types of economic mobility studies (i.e. change of moving from bottom quintile to top quintile, etc.) because they usually only look at income and ignore social class.

That is, suppose Bob is a rich banker. His kid Frank goes to private school and on to an Ivy League college, but seeing how distant and money-focused his dad was growing up, Frank decides to become a writer. Frank is certainly not poor, but he definitely lives on a very modest income and that is what his son John experiences growing up. John, not wanting to have to be in as modest circumstances as his Dad, decides to follow in his grandfather's footsteps and become a banker. His grandfather is even able to introduce him to some colleagues and get him some interviews at top investment banks.

Point being, if you just look at income, it will look like a dynamic economy with lots of economic mobility, with each generation moving from the top to the bottom of the economic latter, and vice versa. In reality, though, nothing really changed at all about their social class and the opportunities that were open to them. Unlike most people in the bottom half of the economic spectrum, Frank was basically there by choice.

Again, you may think this is an extreme example, but in my experience I have seen some version of that multiple times.

Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by Swizec on Monday December 13, 2021 @12:02AM (#29536807)
It’s easy to choose the artist life if your parents can bail you out when shit happens.

A little harder if you’re expected to be the bail out for your parents.

Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by sfifs on Monday December 13, 2021 @01:17AM (#29537212)
Very true. I've literally seen this play out with some friends and cousins in extended family in the last 10-15 years. At a critical period, some had to find work to support the family especially as the health of parents started failing, the ones who could rely on family wealth were able to focus full time or almost full time on their art and are now climbing the echelons as established artists.
Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by achillesheels on Monday December 13, 2021 @01:26AM (#29537255)
This is no different than historical standards of artwork. Indeed, it is from those who can afford to sustain an independent spirit, where genuine artistry extends itself into the human pursuit of perfection. When money is not an object this eternal motivation can progress itself unhindered.
Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by Jensson on Monday December 13, 2021 @12:10AM (#29536848)
Lots of poor people live with their parents, you see that all over the world. Also lots of rich people disown their kids. That has more to do with the mentality of your parents than anything else.
Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by abhinai on Monday December 13, 2021 @12:32AM (#29536957)
I’m putting this quote on Twitter. :). What handle should I use to credit you?
Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by derangedHorse on Monday December 13, 2021 @07:14AM (#29538878)
I don't think the amount of "rich" people (and their descendants) are a significant enough proportion of the population to render the results completely inert.