News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by forgotmyoldname on Sunday December 12, 2021 @09:53PM (#29536051)
I mean, wars were fought over that and revolutions had. People decidedly did not like royalty, large so-wealthy-it's-hard-to-achieve groups, being so far above them. For a while, people much preferred knowing they could work hard or smart and make progress from the bottom to the top 20%.

We're talking about the top 20% here. Not the top 0.1%.

Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by fourtrees on Sunday December 12, 2021 @10:25PM (#29536263)
This is one of my big take-aways from the article. My great-(great?-)-grandparents from Eastern Europe armed with nothing but excellent numeracy, some English, and the clothes on their backs. They could reliably expect to enter move out of post-immigration poverty based on skills cultivated for the purpose of success in the US. My great-x-grandfather ended up a bank manager. And they passed money and knowledge along to their children, insuring as best they could that their progress wouldn't be lost, and it wasn't. You've heard this story a thousand times, and I'd bet it happened tens of thousands of times.

But that sort of outcome seems almost impossible in America today due to more factors than I could probably name especially at this hour. But it seems clear to me that America has changed in the last 120-100 years in a way that locks people into their social classes/'earnings quintiles' while perpetuating, I assume to the advantage of the very wealthy, the myth that that old America of extreme social mobility still exists. This is a myth that needs to die if we're to adequately address our problems as a nation. I suspect the solution begins in the education industry.

Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by maxerickson on Sunday December 12, 2021 @10:41PM (#29536358)
As far as earnings, median household income is very achievable (~$68,000). Associates degrees in medical fields lead to $50,000+ salaries. How far those earnings go relative to other periods is debatable.

Catching up in terms of wealth is probably a lot harder (because we continue to get richer).

Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by DarylZero on Sunday December 12, 2021 @11:29PM (#29536618)
Median of all things is always achievable to half of all people everywhere.
Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by piafraus on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @01:11AM (#29548770)
> But that sort of outcome seems almost impossible in America today due to more factors than I could probably name especially at this hour.

Replace numeracy with programming and it happens right and left. We came from Eastern Europe with barely enough money to rent for a few months. Now we are in top percentile of earners in US. And have lot's of friends with a similar story.

Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by defaultprimate on Monday December 13, 2021 @07:50AM (#29539084)
>But that sort of outcome seems almost impossible in America today

Then you don't know enough about how well, for example, African and central Asian refugees or immigrants do in a single generation. Same for Hispanic immigrants within a generation or two.

Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by Swizec on Monday December 13, 2021 @12:40PM (#29541998)
> Then you don't know enough about how well, for example, African and central Asian refugees or immigrants do in a single generation.

In a generation? I moved here from Europe and within ~6 years accumulated as much wealth as my parents did in a lifetime.

The American dream is still alive and kicking for many if not most immigrants.

But my american friends have a fun joke they like to say: "Wow look at that immigrant work ethic! Wish I could work that hard" ... you could

Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by defaultprimate on Monday December 13, 2021 @06:44PM (#29546266)
I'm so happy to hear of your success! Unfortunately not enough people will give you the credit you deserve because you didn't come from a "bad" place.
Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by Swizec on Monday December 13, 2021 @06:49PM (#29546302)
I mean … does it count if there was a (short) civil war when I was 4? Or that my country went from communist dictatorship to EU member in the first 17 years of my life?

“Bad” is extremely relative. Some of my good friends were actively getting bombed by USA just 600km south of my city when I was in high school. That’s like living in SF with an active warzone in LA, if they were in different countries ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by defaultprimate on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @08:05AM (#29551088)
To me, absolutely. To people of a different political persuasion, it's dependent on the color of your skin and how many political points can be scored on the basis of your relative suffering compared to those that are not coming from predominantly "white, European" countries (regardless of how white they may actually be), not the facts of your circumstance.

The plight of a progressive Nigerian immigrant whose family was extremely wealthy prior to immigration is worth more than your story in today's climate.

Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by goodluckchuck on Sunday December 12, 2021 @10:20PM (#29536230)
Doing hard things can be good. We shouldn’t try to stop people from doing things just because others find it difficult.
Re:Americans overestimate social mobility in their country by forgotmyoldname on Monday December 13, 2021 @03:28AM (#29537806)
We shouldn't. But low social mobility and further stratified wealth divisions is a sign that the effort is pointless for a growing number of people.