I think it goes without saying that having an outage is bad, but having an outage which is not confirmed by the service provider is even worse. People complain about that a lot because it's the least they could do.
I don't gripe about it on HN, but it is generally a disappointment to me when I stumble upon something that looks like a significant outage but a company is making no indication that they've seen it and are working on it (or waiting for something upstream of them, as sometimes happens).
I don't think people are "passionate about status page." I think people are unhappy with someone they are supposed to trust straight up lying to their face.
it makes sense that part of marketing yourself as a viable infrastructure upon which other businesses can operate, you’d provide more granular and refined communication to allow better communication up and down the chain instead of forcing your customers to rca your service in order to communicate to their customers.
There's literally millions on the line.
I get that it not being updated is an annoyance, but I cannot figure out why it is the single most discussed thing about this whole event. I mean, entire services were out for almost an entire day, and if you read HN threads it would seem that nobody even cares about lost revenue/productivity, downtime, etc. The vast majority of comments in all of the outage threads are screaming about how the SHD lied.
In my entire career of consulting across many companies and many different technology platforms, never once have I seen or heard of anyone even looking at a status page outside of HN. I'm not exaggerating. Even over the last 5 years when I've been doing cloud consulting, nobody I've worked with has cared at all about the cloud provider's status pages. The only time I see it brought up is on HN, and when it gets brought up on HN it's discussed with more fervor than most other topics, even the outage itself.
In my real life (non-HN) experience, when an outage happens, teams ask each other "hey, you seeing problems with this service?" "yea, I am too, heard maybe it's an outage" "weird, guess I'll try again later" and go get a coffee. In particularly bad situations, they might check the news or ask me if I'm aware of any outage. Either way, we just... go on with our lives? I've never needed, nor have I ever seen people need, a status page to inform them that things aren't working correctly, but if you read HN you would get the impression that entire companies of developers are completely paralyzed unless the status page flips from green to red. Why? I would even go as far to say that if you need a third party's SHD to tell you if things aren't working right, then you're probably doing something wrong.
Seriously, what gives? Is all this just because people love hating on Amazon and the SHD is an easy target? Because that's what it seems like.