Absolutely not true. I have only anecdotal evidence: I live and work in a nation where unions are everywhere and I see rockstars and specialists getting paid way more than their team mates, everywhere I look.
Can you supply any evidence to support your claim that top performers often see compensation fall?
Personally, even if I believed myself to be the mythical 10x developer, I would still advocate for unions, because
a) Unions help with more than just pay; they make working conditions and benefits vastly better
b) I care about the people around me being paid fairly, too
c) If I'm genuinely good enough to be at the top of whatever pay scale there ends up being, I'm confident that a union will make sure that's enough money to live comfortably, and that's all I need.
I have negative interest in ever having a lifestyle in which the difference between $150k/yr and $200k/yr actually affects what I can do for myself or how I can live.
There are many more below-average comps in tech than above average, because the high end skews really high. So the majority of tech workers should actually see more compensation when negotiating collectively.