Re:Magnus Carlsen retains title after winning lopsided match
by WJW on Saturday December 11, 2021 @08:36AM
(#29520740)
If we take it outside the esports realm, you could say the vast majority of sports has been "solved" since cars are trivially faster than humans, trebuchets are way better for throwing things over long distances, hydraulic cylinders beat anyone at lifting heavy stuff, etc. Nobody is advocating to stop holding athletics events because machines can do the specific task better, so why should we stop holding chess events for humans because a computer can do it better?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Magnus Carlsen retains title after winning lopsided match
by glenstein on Saturday December 11, 2021 @09:22AM
(#29521036)
Well I agree with your conclusion, I do think chess is meaningfully different from your examples.
Chess is often played on software and tracked on software, and my understanding is that there are sometimes issues related to cheating.
You can't similarly use the strength of hydraulic cylinders to aid your strategic skills in a heavy lifting contest, or trebuchet skills, etc