Re:First employee of startup? You are probably getting screwed
by wpietri on Thursday September 01, 2011 @06:19PM
(#2952045)
I think your broad point is good: startup employees should definitely negotiate for a fair share. But your math is loony tunes.
First off, he won't be on reduced salary for 4 years. Seed-round startups may pay below-market salaries, but with later rounds they typically bump people to market rates. The same applies to things like health insurance, 401k, and the like. He's betting maybe a year of reduced income.
Second, the notion of 3 months severance is... very generous. And unnecessary. At least here in San Francisco, the time between jobs for startup-loving engineers is approximately zero. (Or negative. We just hired somebody from a failed startup and would have been happy to bring her on board early if she needed to work part time to responsibly close out her last gig.)
Third, I'd call the career risk negative. In recruiting, I look for people with past startup experience, failed or not. And one shouldn't account for opportunity cost here. If he has a better opportunity, he should take it. If one comes up, he might; he's not chained to the desk or anything.
You're also ignoring time. It's not like the developer is putting in cash early on as founders and investors do; his contribution comes gradually, and he can quit at any time. Seed money buys much more equity than A or B round money, and for good reason: the risk declines over time.
Developers should definitely negotiate, but only with a clear idea of the negotiating landscape, including how the funding structure of typical startups looks. The should also some notion of the marketplace. If a developer wants 20% of the company when somebody as good will do it for 2%, then they're going to be out no matter what math they use to justify their demands.
First off, he won't be on reduced salary for 4 years. Seed-round startups may pay below-market salaries, but with later rounds they typically bump people to market rates. The same applies to things like health insurance, 401k, and the like. He's betting maybe a year of reduced income.
Second, the notion of 3 months severance is... very generous. And unnecessary. At least here in San Francisco, the time between jobs for startup-loving engineers is approximately zero. (Or negative. We just hired somebody from a failed startup and would have been happy to bring her on board early if she needed to work part time to responsibly close out her last gig.)
Third, I'd call the career risk negative. In recruiting, I look for people with past startup experience, failed or not. And one shouldn't account for opportunity cost here. If he has a better opportunity, he should take it. If one comes up, he might; he's not chained to the desk or anything.
You're also ignoring time. It's not like the developer is putting in cash early on as founders and investors do; his contribution comes gradually, and he can quit at any time. Seed money buys much more equity than A or B round money, and for good reason: the risk declines over time.
Developers should definitely negotiate, but only with a clear idea of the negotiating landscape, including how the funding structure of typical startups looks. The should also some notion of the marketplace. If a developer wants 20% of the company when somebody as good will do it for 2%, then they're going to be out no matter what math they use to justify their demands.