News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by tastyfreeze on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:30PM (#29514395)
This is what happens when the buyer doesn't care what the price is because its not their money and the seller doesn't publish prices to allow comparison. Insurance companies only care if a price is outside of "normal" as they can just increase premiums as hospitals push "normal" continually higher.

Hospitals make ridiculous profit. Insurance companies make ridiculous profit. Neither of them care at all what the real customer gets charged.

See also Federally guaranteed student loans

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by ethbr0 on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:50PM (#29514666)
> Hospitals make ridiculous profit.

"It depends."

Non-trauma hospitals in affluent areas that perform lots of elective procedures make a lot of profit.

Trauma centers in less-affluent, usually urban or rural, areas that deliver emergency care almost always run at a loss, and are subsidized by city / state / federal funds to maintain capability.

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by derekjdanserl on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:03PM (#29514816)
Whether it’s hospitals, hosipital owners, doctors, or other healthcare industry benefactors, someone is making a killing beyond just the insurance companies. Ballooning administration is not only a cause but a symptom, which is why free market solutions can’t overcome the problem. Establishing new healthcare institutions will depend on the existing healthcare industry, which will expect the same profits or it won’t cooperate. There is no way around the fact that free-market healthcare is just deeply immoral and inhumane.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by tastyfreeze on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:24PM (#29515036)
Your entire argument is based on the assumption that healthcare is a free-market which it is obviously not. The mechanisms of price discovery are not present to all players in the market. When there is an unbalance in information in any market it will always be detrimental to the player with less information. The way to fix the problem is to create a free-market.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by lotsofpulp on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:27PM (#29515654)
There never will be a free market due to inability to negotiate prices and obtain quotes.

A person who had a stroke is not going to be evaluating offers from various surgeons. Nor are 99% of people going to know what healthcare they need or don’t need.

That is the service a managed care organization provided (aka insurance company).

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by tynpeddler on Friday December 10, 2021 @07:43PM (#29517281)
Spending for emergency health care is between 2%-7% of total US health care spending depending on who you ask. It's an important consideration of course, but the vast majority of health care can exist in a market to one extent or another.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by derekjdanserl on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:08PM (#29522920)
My entire argument is based on the fact that a free-market healthcare system is not even an option. Frankly, a free-market economy of any sort is a utopian fantasy. Healthcare is just a useful case study of the problems.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by tastyfreeze on Saturday December 11, 2021 @04:36PM (#29524500)
My point is that we do not and have not had a free market in health care. So to say that free market healthcare can't work then using the current system as an example is a flawed argument to the point that it is nonsensical.

The incentives for the current system are to continually increase cost. The only way to fix that is with a free market or price controls. Price controls cause a whole different set of problems. The best solution is a free market for the routine and elective parts of healthcare with insurance to cover the rare unexpected events. Everybody gets to manage their risk how they please and healthcare cost comes down due to market forces.

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by staircasebug on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:23PM (#29515604)
US healthcare is most definitely not free market.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by derekjdanserl on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:10PM (#29522934)
As I said, a “free-market” solution isn’t even an option.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by handrous on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:49PM (#29514655)
> This is what happens when the buyer doesn't care what the price is because its not their money and the seller doesn't publish prices to allow comparison.

The norm in most systems (in developed states, anyway) is that the buyer doesn't care what the price is, to at least the same degree that they don't in ours. Yet they're all much cheaper than our system.

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by mikem170 on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:03PM (#29514815)
Most of those other systems have price controls for everything, like Medicare does in the U.S.

The U.S. is different because we allow corporations to lobby/bribe/buy politicians, which most other developed countries consider to be corruption.

So we have a health care system optimized for profits, not people.

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by handrous on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:08PM (#29514875)
Bingo, see my post elsewhere in this thread :-)

I'm no expert but have been reading about this for a couple decades now, and the consistent element in every non-US system in developed countries, despite a vast variety of approaches, is indeed price controls, either explicit or de facto. I'm highly skeptical of any reform attempt in the US that doesn't have that as a central element, due to, you know, gestures at the rest of the world.

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by derekjdanserl on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:10PM (#29514894)
That’s right. But the employer-dependent health insurance arrangement in the U.S. was implemented as an alternative to the various political dynamics that regulate most countries’ healthcare systems and it has successfully done so.

The problem, in other words, is that a truly free-market healthcare system would be politically infeasible in a major first-world nation. So instead of a public healthcare system that would provide minimal healthcare services to all citizens, they tied it to employment, effectively moving it from the consumer market to the labor market. So this arrangement, like most neoliberal policies including Obamacare, has served merely to buy more time for the ruling class. And worst of all it has worked.

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by WillPostForFood on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:09PM (#29514884)
FWIW, the institution in the article, Scripps Health, is a non-profit. Would be interesting to see where the money is going.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by throwaway0a5e on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:17PM (#29514970)
Hospitals are routinely nonprofit orgs. I assume scripps overpays everyone and pays for crap it just doesn't need like hospitals do.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by evergrande on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:40PM (#29514520)
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by nebula8804 on Friday December 10, 2021 @05:18PM (#29516132)
I've seen this chart blasted around the mainstream media and I feel it is sort of cheating. The categories below the 0% line: Cellphone Service, Software, Toys and TVs all benefited mainly from one miracle innovation: Moore's Law. Other than that, have they really done anything else innovative to keep prices that low? If you eliminate anything that mainly benefited from Moore's law then you can derive a very different picture from the chart.

I guess we should be thankful to Moore's law and figure out how to apply it to Childcare, College, and hospital services? I guess thats where Elon Musks's robot comes in to play. It can teach you skills to get a job, take care of your kids, and then perform your surgery. Problem solved! :)

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by afsafsaf on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:37PM (#29514481)
Shouldn't the insurance company care because if they can reduce their premiums, they can be more competitive for employers/purchasers? I don't understand why the insurance company isn't cost driven.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by pmalynin on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:39PM (#29514513)
Insurance companies are require to put a certain % of the premiums towards actual healthcare. In other words administrative fees (read profit) is capped as a % of the premium. The higher the premium the higher the profit.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by huitzitziltzin on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:56PM (#29514736)
Administrative fees =/= “profit”. That is wrong.

Administrative fees include profit, but also salaries, IT expenses, whatever other costs it takes to actually run an insurer.

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by s1artibartfast on Friday December 10, 2021 @08:07PM (#29517412)
Is the rest correct?

That is to say, there is an incentive for higher overall insurance spend, because it allows for higher admin fees (including profit)

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by SomewhatLikely on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:48PM (#29514646)
These ridiculous markups existed before those caps imposed by the ACA.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by SkittyDog on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:08PM (#29514878)
The ACA did not impose those caps, in the first place. It merely standardized them.

State insurance laws have mandated the same kind of caps for decades... I believe they date back to around WWII, but I don't know for certain.

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by SkittyDog on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:06PM (#29514851)
Another poster mentioned this, bur I think it's worth talking about in more detail, because it's at the heart if exactly what's broken about US health care.

Every US state has laws that prohibit insurance companies from collecting "too much" profit from the premiums they charge their customers. In most states, the limit is given as a percentage of pure profit. So insurers set their premiums based on their expected payout costs plus operating expenses, and usually make premium adjustments on an annual basis.

(That's why most US drivers received a bunch of rebates from our auto insurers, early in the COVID pandemic. The sudden unexpected drop in accident rates drastically reduced the insurers payout costs. They were required by law to return the excess.)

The intended purpose of these laws was to protect consumers from predatory insurance companies. But in modern practice, with basically zero effective cost controls on medicine, it's created a perverse incentive: Rising healthcare costs are the easiest opportunity for health insurers to increase their absolute profits... All they have to do is sit back and let health care providers keep raising their prices.

But:

• the costs are passed only indirectly to the consumers who ultimately pay

• the market for health care is so terribly distorted

• health care demand is highly inelastic

So normal market mechanisms (like price signaling) aren't very effective at containing the rise in costs.

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by mox1 on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:48PM (#29515271)
Have you ever "shopped around" for health insurance? Maybe ACA people do, but amongst 2 or 3 giant companies on the exchange..whose prices, features, benefits, etc. are basically the same.

Further, most bigger companies self-insure, and only use the insurance company to provide services. So F100 company partners with Blue Cross Blue Shield just for billing, administration of the plan, etc. What does BCBS care how much surgery costs? They are getting Admin fees the same whether its $5,00 or $10,000. Does a F100 employer really have the time and energy to question whats going on? They just look at the cost last year, raise the price for their employees by %XY and march forward.

Even further, health insurance is incredibly regulated, on a state level. If you have a good idea to "disrupt" the industry, its such a slog to get anything done. Your best bet is to partner with an existing insurance company and go from there.

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by lotsofpulp on Friday December 10, 2021 @07:33PM (#29517231)
BCBS is a network that insurers partake in.

But the managed care organizations (health insurance companies) still complete with each other. UHC, Anthem, Cigna, CVS, Humana, Centene, etc. there are many.

Considering they all have low single digit profit margins per their 10-K reports, it seems evident that there is sufficient competition to incentivize low prices for managed care services.

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by quinnjh on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:43PM (#29514573)
Medical costs being high mean that you have to buy the insurance
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by KoftaBob on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:42PM (#29514553)
> Hospitals make ridiculous profit.

What's interesting about this is that around 75% of hospitals in the US are actually non-profit.

Source: https://www.kff.org/other/state-indicator/hospitals-by-owner...

All this ends up meaning is that any revenue above their expenses is plowed into hiring more and more administrative staff and building new facilities.

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by huitzitziltzin on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:45PM (#29514595)
I’m a health economist who works on hospitals. There is a long-standing question in our literature about whether non profit and for profit hospitals actually act differently. My sense has always been no.

You also leave out one important place for “extra” money to go: salaries within the hospital.

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by seibelj on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:45PM (#29514605)
There are many who work in non-profits with high 6 or 7 figure salaries. Seems like profit to me!

Back in 2015 the president of Boston University raked in $2.5 million https://www.bostonmagazine.com/education/2017/12/11/boston-u...

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by KoftaBob on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:58PM (#29514756)
That's only 50 students worth of tuition for that year, or 0.3% of tuition brought in that year.

While $2.5M is obviously a lot of money, it's a drop in the bucket in terms of how much the university brought in. For universities and hospitals, it's not the high salaries of a few execs, it's the massive amounts of administrative staff.

For the larger hospital systems, several thousand admin staff making 60-70k+ adds up to waaaaay more than the fat paychecks that a dozen execs make.

It's basically a snowball effect. Execs get bonuses for bringing in more revenue, but it's a non-profit so they have to spend it somewhere, so they expand admin and build facilities, rinse repeat.

Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by lrem on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:21PM (#29515008)
Naive question: what if instead admin they would expand actual medical staff?
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by tastyfreeze on Friday December 10, 2021 @03:59PM (#29515377)
That facility may not need more medical staff. Jobs can always be created for administrative purposes. Have any tasks you dont like doing that you have to do with some regularity? Higher somebody to be in charge of that task.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by lrem on Friday December 10, 2021 @04:24PM (#29515611)
I'm not familiar with the US hospitals... But pretty much everywhere else I've seen the doctors and nurses being seriously overworked. Is this different on the other side of the pond?
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by tastyfreeze on Saturday December 11, 2021 @01:56AM (#29519063)
From what I have seen at hospitals in the US the doctors and nurses being overworked doesn't really have anything to do with a shortage of staff. It is more the culture of the business. Hospitals could hire more nurses and doctors and work normal 8 hour shifts. But, a large percentage of medical errors happen at shift changes so there is pressure to have less shift changes.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by tyoma on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:49PM (#29514660)
The hospital system in the article (Scripps), is indeed a non-profit. They even have posters and mailers asking for donations.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by colechristensen on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:53PM (#29514709)
All non-profit means is money doesn’t go to investors. And considering tax and fringe benefits going to “donors” even that is somewhat less true.
Re:Leaked Scripps records reveal automated mark-ups for hosp... by tastyfreeze on Friday December 10, 2021 @02:50PM (#29514672)
Non-profit does not mean that hospitals aren't out to make money. It only means there is some restriction on where the extra money goes.