But the largest component of any "house" is actually the land, which is an asset and thus not in the CPI.
Shelter is consumption, housing is an asset.
> It doesn't produce anything.
Housing produces shelter over time.
No, it doesn't.
Agricultural real estate does, and it is an asset.
We say that machine is an asset.
The machine is eventually "used up" over its lifetime, but that doesn't make it "consumable" in the sense used here - that's true of many assets (we call it "depreciation").
I think "house as button machine" is a consistent model that matches dragonwriter's usage.
No, it's not. Food isn't a durable good that provides “nourishment” for consumption on an ongoing basis; agricultural real estate is, in exactly the same way as residential real estate is for shelter.