News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by gravitronic on Thursday September 01, 2011 @10:42AM (#2950194)
There's a second story here.

Want to build this board yourself? You can't. Try to find information about this Broadcom BCM2835 chip. It only leads back to the Raspberry Pi (and a teardown of the roku 2 media player). Broadcom has not released even a 1-page summary datasheet on this chip. The only specs released are in relation to the Raspberry Pi.

I work for a small tech company that would LOVE to be able to use this chip and as of today it's impossible to even get the datasheet unless you are in "the club" of trusted broadcom customers (or their employee, as one raspberry pi creator is apparently?)

Will this chip ever be sold to the public?

Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by joezydeco on Thursday September 01, 2011 @11:56AM (#2950523)
Not just an employee, but an associate technical director at Broadcom. Others have found that the Raspberry Pi blog posts and etc are coming from Broadcom addresses. They're doing this on company time.

Earlier I thought this was a good marketing thing. Other companies like TI are doing this to get chips in the hands of hackers and spread some goodwill towards future commercial users of their chips.

But, as others have noted, Broadcom is a lot more standoffish with individuals that want access to sample parts and datasheets. So what is Broadcom gaining here? Inroads into educational markets? Access to open-source code written by tinkerers that they can incorporate into future EVKs and chipsets?

Maybe this odd part # is just a series of chips that have failed speedbinning and are being sold off cheaply?

Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by ebenupton on Thursday September 01, 2011 @01:30PM (#2950921)
Would you believe me if I told you we're just nice guys, who used to be kids who couldn't afford computers?
Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by gravitronic on Thursday September 01, 2011 @02:10PM (#2951104)
Hi Eben.

Sorry, I don't mean to detract from what you're doing. I think it's great. I'm very very excited for the Raspberry Pi, both personally and to see what it does globally.

I'm mostly just curious why the chip isn't publicly available. That's all. I personally hope to be able to use this chip in other designs.

Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by ebenupton on Thursday September 01, 2011 @06:29PM (#2952076)
Comparatively few Broadcom chips are available via channel partners. Unfortunately that's just the way our business model works.
Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by sneak on Thursday September 01, 2011 @10:50PM (#2952705)
Well, if the RP organization is getting them for their boards, why not resell them to hobbyists for cost or a very small margin to fund further research?

"Your business" here refers to Broadcom, when the internet generally thinks you're Raspberry Pi. That's the rub.

Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by handelaar on Thursday September 01, 2011 @08:42PM (#2952433)
Maybe you have to be an old fart... I was here for this last time, but then I remembered that 'last time' was 1981.

This still looks like the most important thing of any kind for three decades to those of us who came out of the cheap home computer wave of the early 80s. (Me, I'm even closer to the Raspberry Pi heritage since I got my CS O-Level in 1987 with an IRC-alike network chat app for BBC LANs.)

So try not to cock it up, eh? :D

Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by joezydeco on Thursday September 01, 2011 @09:30PM (#2952542)
I should throttle back my skepticism as well. I understand the intent of the project and I think it's a noble one.

We've already lost an entire generation of potential programmers by not having something like this in the post Apple ][ / BBC Acorn / C64 era. Maybe I'm an old fart by thinking that we don't need a full desktop running at 1080p to make the kids happy, but what do I know anymore.

It's an exciting and ambitious project that only the scale of current SoC systems can achieve. Unfortunately the environment also means licensing of cores and building of these highly complex chips by massive companies like TI and Broadcom. We're all afraid of obsolescence as things accelerate even more, of course, which is probably why we're so hard on Broadcom here.

Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by obarthelemy on Saturday September 10, 2011 @03:20AM (#2981074)
Actually I could never afford a C64 nor Apple II. ZX81 and Spectrum where the thing for me.
Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by tobiasu on Thursday September 01, 2011 @03:26PM (#2951383)
No.
Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by ebenupton on Thursday September 01, 2011 @06:30PM (#2952080)
Commendable skepticism :) It's true though.
Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by gravitronic on Thursday September 01, 2011 @12:02PM (#2950544)
The obvious guess would be their plan is to limit access to the chip until the pi became the "defacto standard" board, similar to the beagleboard or arduino, but I don't know why they're doing it.

They're selling at cost, so it's not to lock in the profit. Whats the benefit of retaining control? Unless they're also going to bring the board to a consumer product and don't want competition, but that's not really their market.

Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by joezydeco on Thursday September 01, 2011 @12:14PM (#2950598)
When it comes to hobby boards, "Defacto standards" don't mean a thing to chip companies. We might like to think it matters...but Broadcom is selling hundreds of millions of parts a year to companies like Apple. Does 50,000 or even 500,000 Raspberry Pis over it's lifetime mean anything to a company like this?
Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by gravitronic on Thursday September 01, 2011 @12:22PM (#2950625)
I would agree with you but clearly it does mean something to them. The Raspberry Pi is getting a chip that is currently not available to the public

As well, as described by Liz in their comments on the Quake 3 post, "Eben works for Broadcom (and they’re giving us some great support – we wouldn’t be able to have got the project this far without their generous help)" http://www.raspberrypi.org/?p=106#comment-1764

Maybe it is only Eben's employment at Broadcom that is helping them get support and the chip sourcing, because otherwise I agree, Broadcom would not care about this.

Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by pointyhat on Thursday September 01, 2011 @11:05AM (#2950296)
Looking at Broadcom's part numbers, it's not a "current" product but it seems to fit in the same series of numbers as their 3G baseband processors and mobile multimedia processors.

I get the feeling it's a new mobile multimedia processor (judging by the HDMI+ARM+3d graphics supprot) which is being conveniently repurposed.

I reckon it'll be on the market soon enough but don't expect to be able to get anything out of Broadcom unless you want volume. Even Farnell don't carry their parts.

Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by gravitronic on Thursday September 01, 2011 @11:18AM (#2950345)
Sounds congruent to what we've experienced in the past.

Even worse is attempting to get customer support from them when you find massive problems in their part but you only ship a few thousand a year...

It just irks me that while the Raspberry Pi in itself is a great product that will be a minor revolution, its impact could be so much greater if this chip was available to all developers.

I guess I should shut my mouth, at least the second product to get the chip is a somewhat philanthropic effort and not another streaming media box.

Re:$25 PC priced like a textbook, works with old analog TVs by pointyhat on Thursday September 01, 2011 @11:25AM (#2950377)
Sounds like any large vendor :)

I agree with you. I'll put my RMS hat on here, but I'm concerned that it's a 100% proprietary platform for education. The old BBC Micros that we had here in the UK were made out of standard bits and had schematics so you could strap what the hell you liked to them (or modify them). They were replaced with utter proprietary crap from Research Machines and it has been like that ever since.

We need some open hardware as well if you ask me.