News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The RNA World Hypothesis by usrbinbash on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @09:14AM (#29484896)
>there is no need for genetic information in a living being able to grow and reproduce.

Yes there is, because one of the principles that define life is the ability to "pass traits onto offspring". This isn't possible without a medium to carry that information.

Self replicating systems do not require information. Self replicating systems that are "alive" by any definiton in the scientific literature, do.

>It cannot produce any RNA without the monomers (nucleotides) and without energy, i.e. a dehydrating agent like ATP

In the same way RNA folds could catalyse RNA synthesis, other folding patterns could break down energy-rich compounds and generate nucleotides.

The one thing they need for this to work, is an enclosed reaction environment, aka a lipid-vesicle, which form spotaneously as long as there are fatty acids.

So no, the RNA world does NOT require some form of non-genetic-host-organisms. Folded RNA molecules within lipid vesicles are likely the earliest form of organised life.

There are no comments on this comment yet.