News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A submarine's weakness: its software? by tablespoon on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @11:44AM (#29474753)
> Torpedos are not bullets, I don't think this is a good analogy.

They aren't, but I'm sure there are operational complications to using them that make the analogy work (e.g. countermeasures).

Re:A submarine's weakness: its software? by throwmamatrain on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @04:40PM (#29490879)
I believe my point was that a modern torpedo hitting a ship is a very high kill probability (mobility or other), being it is guided and explosive.

I would say a missile is more similar to a torpedo. We can look to the Falklands as to how dangerous missiles are against ships. This isn't your grandfathers WWII torpedo.

There is only one other case of an anti-ship missile I can think of off hand, in Desert Storm when a Silkworm was shot at a fleet and shot down with a SeaRAM(?) I think.

I am surprised at the downvotes, but I guess also not. Either way, the information is out there. I agree with the article in that military software is generally awful, but I'm guessing it is not easy to innovate.