I don't understand, do you think landlords don't pay tax, insurance premiums, or maintenance costs for their property? Those are all passed on to tenants with room left over to make the landlord a profit.
Compare paying someone $3k a month to use their asset vs paying a bank ~$3k (probably less) a month while owning that same appreciating asset. When renting, that $3k is gone, a guaranteed loss. With buying, it goes into an asset you can later sell, hopefully at a higher price. Alternatively you can keep it and not have to pay mortgage or rent once it's paid off and still have a place to live. You can also borrow off whatever equity you've built up. Also that mortgage payment is locked in, so you aren't subject to the landlord raising rent after your contract expires in a couple of years.
It's a big investment that you also get to live in. You could lose money on it, but it's unlikely in most populated places, and you will most likely lose less than what you would otherwise pay in rent.
Just make sure you buy in an area / state that isn't shrinking.
> that mortgage payment is locked in
Unless you bought an adjustable rate mortgage. Once you do buy a house, you'll discover that taxes, maintenance, insurance, etc., are not at all locked in. If you don't pay the taxes, you won't have a place to live, as the government will toss you out.
Nearly all people imagine that if they paid $X for a house, then sold it for $(X +Y) that they made $Y profit. They leave out all other costs, like taxes, real estate commissions, insurance, etc., etc., etc.
Ya that's fair based on the payment schedule, banks gotta get their money if you pay it off early; but still more equity than renting.
>Unless you bought an adjustable rate mortgage.
Ya a lot of people got burned by balloon payments in 2008 after the market tanked. They were speculating more so than buying a house to live in many times I suspect. I bought a house in 2002 and it never went below what I paid for it by 2008. I bought at a really good time for my city though.
>Nearly all people imagine that if they paid $X for a house, then sold it for $(X +Y) that they made $Y profit.
I don't think anything ever works that way. Always giving someone a cut.
>They leave out all other costs, like taxes, real estate commissions, insurance, etc., etc., etc.
Ya all that sucks. But if you are renting, you still pay that for somebody else, it's baked in plus profit. If renting wasn't profitable, they wouldn't do it.
Buying a house only makes sense if you're going to stay there 5+ years.
I've owned several homes as I've moved around. Lost money on all but one. My parents lost money on all the houses they bought. Real estate is hardly the guaranteed "wealth builder" people think it is.
I hate mowing the lawn, too.
Oh, and if you build a new house in Washington state, you get to pay sales tax on it! That's another 10% poke in the eye.