News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Evidence for the “great resignation” is thin on the ground by gruez on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:56PM (#29464751)
>For example, if you bought a house, it would have to lose $72K value in 2 years or $144K in 4 years (minus inflation, taxes, maintenance) to break even with paying $3000/month rent.

You're not factoring in transaction costs, maintenance, property taxes, and cost of capital (ie. the downpayment). Transaction costs (eg. relators) are 2.5% on each side, so after buying/selling you're already down 5%. Property taxes and maintenance are estimated to be 1% each, so over 4 years you're down 8%. The cost of capital is hard to quantify, especially if you also factor in appreciation, but housing has historically under-preformed the stock market, so that should theoretically be a non-zero cost there.

Suppose we ignore cost of capital (since that's hard to quantify), let's calculate what that % equates to. According to [1] the price to rent ratios is many cities exceed 30. If we use a price to rent ratio of 30, then a $3000/month rent translates to a house price of $1.08M. Factoring in the % costs from before, that's a cost of $140.4k. That's nearly as big as the $144k loss that you budgeted for, before factoring in drop in home price. The maintenance/property taxes alone is going to eat up more than half of your hypothetical $3000 in rent savings.

[1] https://smartasset.com/mortgage/price-to-rent-ratio-in-us-ci...

>However, if your house appreciates as most do in highly industrialized areas, you basically get paid to live there.

but that's the same force that makes housing unaffordable.

Re:Evidence for the “great resignation” is thin on the ground by stonogo on Monday December 06, 2021 @03:27PM (#29465164)
That's not how realtor fees work. The seller pays them. And plenty of real estate changes hands without the involvement of real estate agents. What you've described is a worst-case scenario which completely ignores the fact that homeowners have a real asset they can then sell.

Further, any of this handwaving about all the fees of ownership apply just as well to whoever owns the property you're renting -- all of which costs they simply pass to the renter. There is no world where renting is as cost-effective as ownership over the long term.

Re:Evidence for the “great resignation” is thin on the ground by gruez on Monday December 06, 2021 @03:37PM (#29465332)
>That's not how realtor fees work. The seller pays them

1. even if you're not paying them, it's baked into the price.

2. OP mentioned buying and selling (for a loss), so he'll eventually have to pay it

3. if you search around, realtor fees are customarily at 6% for the seller, so my estimate of 2.5% for both sides is actually underestimating it.

> What you've described is a worst-case scenario which completely ignores the fact that homeowners have a real asset they can then sell.

I'm using the case that OP himself provided.

>Further, any of this handwaving about all the fees of ownership apply just as well to whoever owns the property you're renting -- all of which costs they simply pass to the renter. There is no world where renting is as cost-effective as ownership over the long term.

Right, I'm not claiming that you're not throwing away any money when renting, just that it's nowhere the full rent, and the numbers aren't as rosy as OP initially suggested (ie. you can lose $144K house value in 4 years, and still break even).

Re:Evidence for the “great resignation” is thin on the ground by lakecresva on Monday December 06, 2021 @03:24PM (#29465122)
> Factoring in the % costs from before, that's a cost of $140.4k.

For a married person with a million dollar home, they'll make ~$150k back from the section 121 nonrecognition provision alone if they ever sell, not to mention the salt and mortgage interest tax deductions. The tax code heavily incentivizes home ownership.

Re:Evidence for the “great resignation” is thin on the ground by gruez on Monday December 06, 2021 @03:42PM (#29465398)
>For a married person with a million dollar home, they'll make ~$150k back from the section 121 nonrecognition provision alone if they ever sell

1. that's on capital gains. If they're selling for a loss in OP's scenario, that works out to a tax savings of $0.

2. realistically speaking this can be factored into the cost of cost of capital (ie. opportunity cost of the downpayment/mortgage payment), but I didn't want to get into that because the calculation can get subjective. Housing has historically under-performed the stock market, but if you're a housing permabull, you might argue that the housing bubble will continue and outperform the stock market, making the opportunity cost of buying a house negative.

>not to mention the salt and mortgage interest tax deductions

that's a savings on mortgage interest, which is a cost that wasn't in my calculations. Including that cost and factoring in that deduction will make the numbers worse, not better.

>The tax code heavily incentivizes home ownership.

no disagreement there.

Re:Evidence for the “great resignation” is thin on the ground by lakecresva on Monday December 06, 2021 @04:23PM (#29465906)
I didn't realize you assumed a loss through the entire thing. Sure, if you ignore the realities of the US property market and begin with the assumption that your home is going to lose six figures in value every few years then yeah I guess renting is better than buying.