Re:Even with Agile and Scrum waterfall will sneak in
by allturtles on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:00PM
(#29464075)
In that case, I have never worked in the context for which Agile was intended, and neither, I suspect, have a significant proportion of all working software developers. That may explain many of the disconnects in these conversations.
Re:Even with Agile and Scrum waterfall will sneak in
by Jtsummers on Monday December 06, 2021 @02:07PM
(#29464156)
Well, that's not the only case it was intended for. But the language around customers is colored by that context.
Re:Even with Agile and Scrum waterfall will sneak in
by geodel on Monday December 06, 2021 @03:18PM
(#29465041)
Indeed. They way I understand Agile/Scrum in enterprises is basically a dogmatic process around implementing a bog standard CRUD app Nth time. Minor details keep changing from customer to customer.
It should be clear to folks that complex technology products in past were not developed by caricature of Waterfall method that Agile peddlers show on slides. Neither today interesting engineering products are developed following some "methodology industry".
This gets to part of the problem in all these discussions. The context that the Agile Manifesto was written in was not in creating Facebook or Google, but in creating software for a defined customer who held a stake in the outcome (had invested capital, along with wanting/needing the results). Once written, something like your Google Docs replacement can get a customer stakeholder, but they won't have it at the start unless you line up early users (and even then, they probably aren't invested).