"My thoughts each release as it evolved, long before Jobs resigned, were "I don't think Jobs is around anymore, if he were, he wouldn't let this crap go".
LaunchPad, Mission Control -- these things were neat at first, but then they got annoying and cumbersome."
Yes, exactly what I thought. Too much junk stuffed in. A more Jobsian-approach would have cut features ruthlessly.
Even the Time Machine-ish file saving time travel is full of holes. I wrote a critique of it whilst wrestling with it was still fresh in my mind.
http://userxperience.posterous.com/document-versioning-inter...
Bits of it are great, but there are so many gotchas and bit of too small UI, it's hard to believe it got much love.
I don't want to add to alarmist dirt tossing, but I've been running Lion since the first public betas.
My thoughts each release as it evolved, long before Jobs resigned, were "I don't think Jobs is around anymore, if he were, he wouldn't let this crap go".
LaunchPad, Mission Control -- these things were neat at first, but then they got annoying and cumbersome.
The new concept of scrolling is not intuitive, whenever I use it, I still get this momentary interrupt in my brain.
It would be intuitive if my fingers were on the screen scrolling, but since they're on a trackpad that's about a foot and 90 degrees away from the screen, it's not intuitive to me.
The UI is getting more Windows control panelish, things are needlessly being abstracted or hidden, but I need these things regularly, so now I have to sort through 2 more views before I get to what I need, or worse, launch Terminal and use 'defaults write'.
I'm not sure why the Dock is there anymore. It feels superfluous with Spotlight search and the non-suck portions of LaunchPad and Mission Control around.
Instead of an elegant transition between Mac OS X and iOS, it seems like clunky patchwork.