"we should discount our belief that the Higgs has a mass at 140GeV by a factor roughly proportionate to the 95% confidence of the result"
I'm sorry but I don't understand what this means in practice. The first part is a Bayesian belief, while the 95% confidence result comes from frequentist analysis. I'm not sure how you can mix the two."If the Higgs were at 140 GeV, it would have 5% probability of producing the results we measured experimentally" is the same as P(Observation | Higgs at 140Gev) = .05
So we can say that
P(Higgs|Observation) = P(Observation|Higgs) * P(Higgs)
-------------------------------
P(Observation)
So given that getting your new belief about the probability of a Higgs Boson at some energy is going to be updated based on your observation, you can see that it ends up being scaled by that exact confidence result. That's sort of an oversimplification, since really you end up calculating the P(O) scaling factor based on P(O|H) among other things, but I hope you can see how they're closely related in practice.For me the important point to communicate was that the article is, let's say, mostly nonsense. Just consider the title:
> A Higgs Setback: Did Stephen Hawking Just Win the Most Outrageous Bet in Physics History?
Never mind the superlatives. There was no "Higgs setback", and the answer to the question is "No". The article does not leave out the correct details, but I'm quite certain it leaves the layman with the feeling that the Higgs search is all but doomed.
About not using a Bayesian approach, though, I don't understand how could you infer the existence or not of the Higgs without it, considering that we can only measure something that is probabilistically correlated to what we want to find.
In other words, what should happen for you to say that we have verified that there is a Higgs boson? I'm pretty confident that it would be some application of Bayes theorem :)
However, as I said above the term "95% confidence" is not related to this reasoning at all. Saying for example "the Higgs mass is not 140 GeV at 95% CL" means precisely: If the Higgs were at 140 GeV, it would have 5% probability of producing the results we measured experimentally. It does not mean "we are 95% sure the Higgs isn't at 140 GeV".