No standard says, or even suggest, that “residential ips are not valid.” However, reputation is an important par of mail security. Most, if not all residential IPs won’t be sending enough mail to even register a reputation (look up your own on https://talosintelligence.com/). This is the main challenge for self-hosters. That and a significant majority of residential ISPs block SMTP traffic, for very obvious reasons. This isn’t some Google/Microsoft conspiracy. SMTP is fundamentally a plain text format that has been abused for the last 30 or so years - 30, because that’s when MIME became a thing.
The vast majority of email routes through a few major email service providers, with gmail the largest, but MS (via O365 hosting) and Yahoo are also likely double-digit market share.
Fwd/Rev DNS Match Yes Last Day Vol. 0.0 Last Month Vol. 0.0 Block Lists 1 BLOCKED IN: pbl.spamhaus.org Email Rep. Poor
Are you proposing that they mark every mail spam that's not on the contact list of user? Otherwise checking signatures doesn't do anything, spammers already use dkim.
The internet is unfortunately not user-centric enough, there is much more value in sending crap html emails "only 10 hours left 50% discount" and scanning your emails than there is to provide users with secure communications.
let's all sign our emails to raise awareness of google's & outlook shortcoming
P.S : we tend not to sign our emails since it is not the standard, standard is de-facto dictated by google and outlook now.
P.P.S : seeing an unsigned email would raise suspicion if the standard was the opposite, a filter could even classify between signed and unsigned
P.P.P.S : you would only bother to verify the identity for the emails you care for
P.P.P.P.S : if you think google does not dictate the standards, feel free to point to me the part of the rfc that mention that residential ips are not valid.