Re:Ask HN: Why salaries are not openly discussed?
by jeroenhd on Saturday December 04, 2021 @08:25PM
(#29445955)
I'm not entirely sure why, but I think it's because many people don't like to brag. If you earn more than the people you're talking to, that could be taken as a "look how much of a big shot I am" kind of comment, even if it wasn't meant to be. There's also a good chance that asking for a raise is futile, in which case jealousy could easily strike.
Some people are discouraged by their managers from discussing their pay; to me, that indicates a bad work environment.
> what does employer gain from it?
The employer can afford to only pay people who are good negotiators more, while keeping the rest at a lower pay or worse benefits. New hires earning more than the old blood because of differences in contracts can also happen. If you get the suggestion to keep quiet about compensation, my guess would be that it's probably because some workers have gotten a worse deal than others and their managers don't want people to leave or ask for a raise.
There are good reasons for why you don't pay two people doing the same work the same amount of money. Maybe one person does the job a lot better, maybe one person has more time off or has negotiated never to work when their favourite sports team is playing. Maybe someone has kids and can't be relied to do overtime in periods of crunch, or maybe someone asked for a newer company car instead of a pay rise. Maybe someone has negotiated special perks that they worry will be taken away if people find out and come asking for the same exceptions.
At the end of the day, there's more to compensation than pure monetary value. People value different kinds of compensation differently, so discussing this objectively gets harder the more flexible your employer gets. It's easy to become outraged about money because it can be easily compared ("Julie earns more than 10 grand more than James!").
There are good reasons why you would only discuss your salary if you have the time to go into details. There are also many bad ones.
If people have the same contract terms, work the same hours and do the same job, then there's no good reason for difference in pay, in my opinion. But, as many people have discovered when companies decided to cut pay when they relocated to a cheaper area, you're not worth what you contribute to the company; only what you can manage the company to spend on you. If you don't have a lot of options, your employer can screw you over significantly.
Some people are discouraged by their managers from discussing their pay; to me, that indicates a bad work environment.
> what does employer gain from it? The employer can afford to only pay people who are good negotiators more, while keeping the rest at a lower pay or worse benefits. New hires earning more than the old blood because of differences in contracts can also happen. If you get the suggestion to keep quiet about compensation, my guess would be that it's probably because some workers have gotten a worse deal than others and their managers don't want people to leave or ask for a raise.
There are good reasons for why you don't pay two people doing the same work the same amount of money. Maybe one person does the job a lot better, maybe one person has more time off or has negotiated never to work when their favourite sports team is playing. Maybe someone has kids and can't be relied to do overtime in periods of crunch, or maybe someone asked for a newer company car instead of a pay rise. Maybe someone has negotiated special perks that they worry will be taken away if people find out and come asking for the same exceptions.
At the end of the day, there's more to compensation than pure monetary value. People value different kinds of compensation differently, so discussing this objectively gets harder the more flexible your employer gets. It's easy to become outraged about money because it can be easily compared ("Julie earns more than 10 grand more than James!").
There are good reasons why you would only discuss your salary if you have the time to go into details. There are also many bad ones.
If people have the same contract terms, work the same hours and do the same job, then there's no good reason for difference in pay, in my opinion. But, as many people have discovered when companies decided to cut pay when they relocated to a cheaper area, you're not worth what you contribute to the company; only what you can manage the company to spend on you. If you don't have a lot of options, your employer can screw you over significantly.