The technical arguments are not sufficiently compelling to undermine the entirely obvious transition to a more big media friendly model in progress.
Further, I'm on the solid majority opinion on all this.
To get past that requires proponents show people need this to be done, they are better off, and that somehow they will be better informed, see more value.
Not gonna happen.
Ok. Obviously you don't need to do anything, but presenting evidence for a claim when asked is a pretty basic standard for discussion around here. Peace out.
You want hard facts on political and power motivated behaviors. Over time, as I said, we will learn more.
And hey, I could be wrong. That will come out too.
It's a chicken and egg issue. You can assume if you have an egg you'll eventually get a chicken, but he's saying "you don't know that 'for sure'" until the chicken hatches. It's just feels like concern trolling.
> They're basically trying to take the position of "It's not real until you can have a scientific or political consensus by APPROVED thought leaders."
This is a bizarre and bad faith summary of my position. I have made no statements about "approved thought leaders". What I said is that evidence has not been provided for the claim that YouTube is deleting comments for criticism of hiding the dislike button. I understand that you believe this to be true implicitly and that no evidence is needed to make the claim, but I reject the suggestion that your claim doesn't need evidence. Lacking evidence, you lash out and label me a troll... a foreboding omen for the possibility of civil discussion.
Go back to reddit.
Seriously, and with due respect, I do not need your endorsement. In the court of public opinion, it's all about the passers by and how this conversation plays out over an extended amount of time. You have put your thoughts here, as have I and we both get to do that!
Bonus: Seems a reasonable conversation. I like those.
My perspective is that of a student of corruption, these general dynamics over a broad range of contexts. There are some basic truisms in play here that speak very strongly to the opinion I expressed.
That's why I lead with, "of course they are", because "that is how these things go."
Time tested, production proven basic wisdom right there. Our history is littered with this crap, and the tech, context, etc... will change, but the humans really don't.
This is a human issue, not a technical one.