Re:Magnus Carlsen wins longest world chess championship game...
by zeven7 on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:36PM
(#29435893)
I am not a chess player, but as a go player who has played on several different servers, all of that can be true and it can still be easier to compare progress relative to a real world association on one server vs another. ajkjk's point still makes sense to me.
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins longest world chess championship game...
by amalcon on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:43PM
(#29435986)
I think there's a third, bigger reason: FIDE rating is based on classical time controls. Nobody uses classical time controls online for various reasons. Even rapid is a somewhat different skill set than classical.
Of course these things are correlated, but e.g. there have been times in the world championship when one of the players thought about a position for 20+ minutes before making a move. That's hard to do, and requires very strong visualization skills.
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins longest world chess championship game...
by tehnub on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:47PM
(#29436032)
There are FIDE ratings for other time controls too. Here are the top blitz players for example: https://ratings.fide.com/top.phtml?list=men_blitz
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins longest world chess championship game...
by amalcon on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:49PM
(#29436054)
Oh interesting, I didn't know that. Thanks!
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins longest world chess championship game...
by not_kurt_godel on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:36PM
(#29435892)
The bottom line is still that a chess.com rating will be more indicative of what a theoretical FIDE/USCF rating would be, and there's value in that, even if it's not rigorously tethered.
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins longest world chess championship game...
by thaurelia on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:46PM
(#29436023)
Comparison sites will give you ±150 Elo relative error (with I assume P=0.95).
150 Elo on levels below 2700 FIDE is almost night and day difference.
Chess.com ratings show nothing about theoretical FIDE ratings. Comparison tables have been built with data mining and lucky guesses, there's no quality difference between Chess.com <-> FIDE and LiChess <-> FIDE.
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins longest world chess championship game...
by ajkjk on Saturday December 04, 2021 @01:37AM
(#29439180)
Yes they do show 'something'. They correlate with them.
It's just a fact that chess.com ratings are closer to 'real' ratings than Lichess are. It's not perfect but that doesn't mean it's a zero-information statement either.
- they use different rating systems (Elo for FIDE, Glicko-2 for LiChess and afair, Glicko/Glicko-2 for chess.com)
- ELO / Glicko rating is calculated for a _player pool_. Which means it will never correspond between FIDE-registered players and chess websites because they don't have the same player base.
It has nothing to do with being “inflated” or “unrealistic”. The difference is “by design”