Re:New SiFive RISC-V core P650 with 40% IPC increase
by userbinator on Thursday December 02, 2021 @08:11PM
(#29425404)
It can try... but you're basically trying to "decompile" or "compress" code to a higher level, and that's not easy nor efficient. If something relatively simple like ADC is difficult, think of something like an entire encryption/hash round, which competing CISC processors already have dedicated instructions for. In the case that you do manage to make that work, there's still the matter of those extra instructions taking up valuable space in caches and memory bandwidth.
Hence why I don't think "RISC is the future" unlike a lot of other proponents; I think a CISC with uop-based decoding will be more scalable and performant. Even ARMs have moved a little in that direction.
Re:New SiFive RISC-V core P650 with 40% IPC increase
by wbl on Friday December 03, 2021 @08:20AM
(#29429675)
Classic CISC processors like the VAX had lots of memory to memory instructions complex looping constructs etc. Special ops that are register to register aren't anti-RISC.
Hence why I don't think "RISC is the future" unlike a lot of other proponents; I think a CISC with uop-based decoding will be more scalable and performant. Even ARMs have moved a little in that direction.