News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon EC2 M1 Mac Instances by jedberg on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:17PM (#29424937)
One issue is what gets shut down when you hit the max? If you have an EC2 instance running and you hit the max, do they shut it off? Would customers understand that and be ok with it? What if you have an S3 bucket? Should they just delete the data? That's probably not what you want.

You can basically do max bill now -- you can set up a cloud watch alarm for billing and when it reaches a certain price, run a script. Your script could just shut everything down and delete everything, or do whatever is appropriate for your account. That's their solution to this.

Also they don't have instant feedback on usage -> cost. They batch process it. So if you get a huge spike in usage, AWS may not even know that for a while. They could in theory be willing to eat the cost of usage between it happening and their processing, but are probably unwilling.

Re:Amazon EC2 M1 Mac Instances by PowerfulWizard on Thursday December 02, 2021 @08:31PM (#29425545)
There must be a process for unpaid bills, whatever that process is they could just enact it at the user's threshold instead of their own threshold. Ideally a soft limit that would disable networking and resource creation and then later a hard limit where your account is wiped out.

Because of the potential overhang before the billing system catches up I think it would be appropriate to lower the service quotas on this type of account. I'm not sure if the customer can lower their own quotas which would be an alternate cost control strategy but a beginner wouldn't know to think of that anyway. The solution with billing alerts is good at a company level but too much for a beginner in my opinion.

I know unexpected costs were a concern for me when I started using AWS as a student in 2008 and it is still a concern for people in the same situation, just with so much more complexity on top of it all. It will be a tiny fragment of their revenue but as time goes on a higher and higher level of expertise is required to get started, even though you can accomplish a lot with just the free tier. The amount of progress they've made on this issue in the last 13 years is just not impressive.

Re:Amazon EC2 M1 Mac Instances by jedberg on Thursday December 02, 2021 @08:46PM (#29425637)
> There must be a process for unpaid bills

They lock your account but keep all the resource active and the bill just keeps going up until you pay to get back in.

Re:Amazon EC2 M1 Mac Instances by notreallyserio on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:48PM (#29425214)
Yeah, shut off EC2 instances, block access to all resources, etc. Preserve bucket data and other storage for N days or $M max allowance (ultimately billable) before deleting. AWS could limit how much storage they make available to someone with a budget, reducing their risk substantially.

It's pretty easy stuff, IMO, but the upside for them is low -- after all they are already #1.

Re:Amazon EC2 M1 Mac Instances by jedberg on Thursday December 02, 2021 @08:47PM (#29425647)
That might work for you, but not everyone. They might even have legal trouble with such a system, if they delete data that was required to be retained for example. You're not thinking of all the edge cases.
Re:Amazon EC2 M1 Mac Instances by EricE on Thursday December 02, 2021 @09:37PM (#29426017)
Why is data remotely their problem?

If you don't have your data backed up in something other than Amazon, Amazon is the LEAST of your worries.