News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:100 years of whatever this will be by yourabstraction on Thursday December 02, 2021 @11:19AM (#29418110)
You make a good point about software development in general, but I don't think it applies to things as fundamentally revolutionary as crypto. Sometimes system _do_ have to be completely re-thought from the ground up. I don't believe it's possible for our current financial systems to morph into an open network for storing and transmitting value (the internet of money as some call crypto).
Re:100 years of whatever this will be by Joeri on Thursday December 02, 2021 @11:47AM (#29418590)
Let’s assume (and that’s a big if) that crypto is a fundamentally better foundation to base finance on. Even if it is, we cannot presently know that it is, and we cannot predict what its unique failure scenarios will be and how to counter them. Therefore for me arguing a headlong dive into crypto is indeed like a junior developer arguing for the big rewrite.

I also fail to see the fundamental difference between crypto and gold. Anyone can mine gold, there is no central authority creating gold or determining its value. Gold is just as decentral a currency as crypto. If gold was not the solution to the financial system, why would crypto be?

Re:100 years of whatever this will be by jakub_g on Thursday December 02, 2021 @12:06PM (#29418920)
> Anyone can mine gold

Bizarre comment - there's only a handful of places in the world where gold is located (most countries have close to zero), and they're probably controlled by some powerful private entity and probably under a gov license.

Re:100 years of whatever this will be by Negitivefrags on Thursday December 02, 2021 @12:14PM (#29419071)
Nothing is preventing you just going to a gold producing river and panning for gold.

You will be just as effective doing that as someone who just runs the Bitcoin client at home.

Getting serious requires specialised hardware setup and capital intensive operations in both gold mining and Bitcoin mining.

Re:100 years of whatever this will be by aaronharnly on Thursday December 02, 2021 @01:58PM (#29420741)
Interestingly enough, between 1933 and 1975, it was a criminal offense for U.S. citizens to own or trade gold anywhere in the world, with exceptions for some jewelry and collector's coins.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_Reserve_Act

Re:100 years of whatever this will be by yourabstraction on Thursday December 02, 2021 @12:07PM (#29418946)
I agree that gold and Bitcoin have some very key similarities, but gold and crypto in general are quite different. With regards to Bitcoin, yes they're both stores of value, but Bitcoin has the added ability to transact globally and be much more divisible. Bitcoin seems to have settled into two roles within the greater crypto ecosystem; store of value and reserve currency for the entire crypto economy. Now there are also things happening in the Bitcoin payments space using lightening, but I don't think there will ever be a large appetite for payments using a deflationary currency (It's your savings account, not your checking account).

But outside of Bitcoin there is a ton of cool stuff happening in the DeFi space which could have big implications for our financial systems. One example is stablecoins which has a much better chance of being used in payment systems than a store of value like Bitcoin. In general I don't see this stuff replacing the financial system so much as finance companies slowly adopting crypto on the backend. Just like companies adopted internet technology as it allowed them to run more efficiently.

Re:100 years of whatever this will be by themacguffinman on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:50PM (#29422334)
Crypto blockchains are a technical boondoggle in a financial system that already has trusted institutions. The whole costly & complex system of blockchain transactions is designed to simulate trust without authorities, I don't see any technical reason why it would be more efficient than a simple encrypted packet + an optimized database that a regulated institution can implement when it doesn't need to simulate trust. Even Proof of Stake is totally unnecessary in a regulated financial system.
Re:100 years of whatever this will be by zarzavat on Thursday December 02, 2021 @12:22PM (#29419200)
The fundamental difference between cryptocurrency and gold is that cryptocurrency can be transmitted whereas gold can only be carried.

Try carrying a bar of gold across a border and you'll end up in an interrogation room.

Re:100 years of whatever this will be by alchemism on Thursday December 02, 2021 @01:46PM (#29420537)
That is why diamonds are traditionally used for that sort of transfer.
Re:100 years of whatever this will be by soco on Thursday December 02, 2021 @12:59PM (#29419784)
How about declaring it in the first place?
Re:100 years of whatever this will be by zarzavat on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:11AM (#29429098)
You'll still end up in the room regardless. Most governments are pretty interested in people who carry large amounts of gold through borders! They might make you forfeit that gold if they don't like your answers, or if you have too much.

Cryptocurrency's digital nature makes it much more useful than gold. It can be stored like gold in a vault, but it can also be transmitted over the internet like a bank transfer. It's pretty incredible stuff.

Re:100 years of whatever this will be by dcow on Thursday December 02, 2021 @12:29PM (#29419322)
Not totally disagreeing with the rest of your comment, but we haven't had a gold standard for awhile now, and that’s the problem. Lifting fiat off gold lets institutions play games with fiat to increase their fiat with the appearance of being a good steward of fiat. This is what people don’t trust.
Re:100 years of whatever this will be by curiousllama on Thursday December 02, 2021 @11:47AM (#29418595)
You're right, but it's because we made the conscious decision to not have a totally-open playing field after seeing how it went.

It's like the old code base: we made a bunch of incremental design decisions over 50+ years that are all layered on top of each other. They are now so complex that nobody can coherently explain the whole thing. But does that mean we should burn it down? Not necessarily. If we rebuild from scratch, we're liable to simply re-learn why we built the hacky solution in the first place.

Crypto is great. It's a wonderful innovation - and will likely succeed in many ways. But it won't replace central banks and regulators (except, potentially, by replicating them) because the institutions are actually useful.

Re:100 years of whatever this will be by yourabstraction on Thursday December 02, 2021 @11:57AM (#29418754)
I don't think crypto will replace the financial systems we have or that we should burn down what's already there. I think the way it will play out is that it will increasingly get used on the backend of the legacy financial system. So the front end will appear similar to the consumer with the same usability and protections they're used to, while the backend will be settling transaction using a variety of crypto networks. The consumer will then have the option of using the centralized front ends or communicating directly with the decentralized crypto protocols.
Re:100 years of whatever this will be by MauranKilom on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:36PM (#29422144)
What is the benefit of using crypto on the backend?
Re:100 years of whatever this will be by icehawk on Thursday December 02, 2021 @12:08PM (#29418962)
The point makes sense since a lot of the complexity of the current financial system isn't because of the money, it's because of the /people./

The complexity comes from the rules enacted to shield people from bad actors, and that's just going to be re-applied to crypto in some way shape or form.

Re:100 years of whatever this will be by dmitriid on Thursday December 02, 2021 @11:59AM (#29418788)
> as fundamentally revolutionary as crypto.

This is a huge claim, and needs to have just as huge of a proof.

However, all cryptos can offer is poof (as in poof, and gone) than proof.

Re:100 years of whatever this will be by yourabstraction on Thursday December 02, 2021 @12:59PM (#29419791)
Well of course there's no way to prove it now. Could you have proved how revolutionary the internet would be in its early days? You have to be open minded and extrapolate from the principles of the new system and its interactions with society at large to _guess_ how impactful it may be. I believe the fundamental principles of crypto (open, permissionless, decentralized, global, neutral, etc.) make it highly likely to revolutionize finance.
Re:100 years of whatever this will be by dmitriid on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:21PM (#29421933)
> Could you have proved how revolutionary the internet would be in its early days?

Yes. Yes, you could. 10 years after ARPANet was made public you already had things like France's Minitel.

Blockchains? They still have zero use cases: https://medium.com/@kaistinchcombe/ten-years-in-nobody-has-c...

> You have to be open minded and extrapolate

Ah yes. "Revolutionary tech", and all you have to do is blindly believe in it.

Re:100 years of whatever this will be by yourabstraction on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:53PM (#29422381)
This zero use cases rhetoric is really low effort. Here are some just off the top of my head.

sovereign store of value (useful if your government sucks)

permissionless payments (funding wikileaks)

private/anonymous transactions (Monero)

event tickets (good use of NFTs)

synthetic assets (anyone/anywhere can speculate on TSLA)

decentralized asset exchange - AMM

decentralized prediction markets

DAO - a new way for people to organize and form internet native companies

Re:100 years of whatever this will be by dmitriid on Friday December 03, 2021 @03:06AM (#29427726)
> This zero use cases rhetoric is really low effort.

It isn't if you cared to at least read the link I provided

As to your use cases. First the obvious ones:

- event tickets. Have literally zero need for blockchain. NFTs are scam, and nothing but scam. All the fictional properties ascribed to ticketing via NFTs I've covered in my to responses to this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29282931

- synthetic assets, decentralized asset exchange, decentralized prediction markets. Require neither bitcoin, nor blockchains nor crypto. Used almost exclusively for trading fictional tokens, scams, and pretending it's innovation.

The less obvious ones:

- sovereign store of value (useful if your government sucks)

"Let's convert our value into a fictional token that has no value outside the fictional world, and can't be used for anything but buying other digital tokens".

Buy food? Oh, you have to convert it to real money (because no one in the world, especially not in the world where government sucks, accepts these fictional tokens). Or if someone does accept it, oops, random transaction fees just doubled your cost.

Buy actual physical assets? "When your government sucks", people prefer dollars and euro to fictional tokens.

- permissionless payments

This is a very tiny part that is arguably useful, but it comes with a plethora of issues that make them unusable for wide adoption. Among them, reversibility, enforcement.

Re:100 years of whatever this will be by serverholic on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:04PM (#29423382)
How a tech enthusiast doesn't think these are all extremely interesting is beyond me.
Re:100 years of whatever this will be by dmitriid on Friday December 03, 2021 @03:07AM (#29427731)
All of these are as interesting as working at a bank or at a stock exchange (and those can be significanty more interesting due to amount of data they process).

Unless, of course, you're interested in outright scams like NFT. Yup, those are "interesting".