Re:The American prison system’s war on reading
by joshuamorton on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @09:06PM
(#29399839)
I think you're taking a particularly uncharitable reading of GPs "so what". I read it precisely as asking the other person to make the value tradeoff argument.
Re:The American prison system’s war on reading
by kbenson on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @09:56PM
(#29400148)
Perhaps, but Merriam-Webster defines the idiom as meaning "should not be found objectionable", which squares with how I interpreted it. You're right that it's possible it wasn't meant that way though.
My objection is to what I see as a cavalier attitude towards the injuries and deaths of those we've incarcerated, which I think we have a clear duty to try to alleviate. We are legally required to not torture and or injure them, and I don't think turning a blind eye towards what happens in the environment we force them to be in diminishes our responsibility with respect to that.