News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.K. regulators order Meta to sell Giphy by ethbr0 on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @10:06AM (#29392878)
It's an interesting point, and ultimately kind of boils down to "Is a more profitable company good for consumers?"

To which the answer seems inarguably "Sometimes." Scale that reduces production costs (and therefore prices), yes. Or prices could be maintained and the increased profits given to shareholders, in which case no.

I think the broader question is "What systemic features exist that make giant companies more efficient than a network of smaller, independent companies?"

And to that, I'd argue that in the 21st century, not many. The market and communication B2B inefficiencies that drove conglomeration in the 20th century have most been reduced to zero.

The only reason to have a hyperscale company these days is to deploy capital at scale in loss-making enterprises in hopes of capturing market share... and I'm not sure that's something that's been healthy in aggregate?

Re:U.K. regulators order Meta to sell Giphy by rlpb on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @10:31AM (#29393170)
> And to that, I'd argue that in the 21st century, not many. The market and communication B2B inefficiencies that drove conglomeration in the 20th century have most been reduced to zero.

There's still the efficiencies of mass production for physical goods. For digital services that include any element of social network, there's the network effect. I think these are still a significant factor in most markets today. For match-making services in particular, brand recognition is important; otherwise users have difficulty in _finding_ quality from a directory of smaller, independent companies. And arranging effective federation, while possible, is expensive and development of such systems is slow.

Re:U.K. regulators order Meta to sell Giphy by ethbr0 on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @10:56AM (#29393504)
True. But I imagine what would evolve would be a few B2C "face" brands, backed by a web of unmentioned B2B companies that customers never directly interact with.

Which is essentially the dynamic now, except the B2C last mile companies can parlay their relationship and just buy everything high value upstream of them.

Which... I'm not sure is great for competition.

Anything that moved the market away from one in which all customers are "an Apple customer" or "a Google customer" or "a Facebook customer", with those companies unconstrained in their ability to leverage that, seems better.

Re:U.K. regulators order Meta to sell Giphy by BurningFrog on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @10:43AM (#29393344)
A major reason to group companies together in a "hyperscale" company is to influence government regulation, which is where you can access real money and power.