News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by munificent on Monday November 29, 2021 @05:36PM (#29386193)
> in this case the rewarding effect of acoustic stimuli in humans, can be powerfully maximized. There must exist patterns in music-space that would have profoundly greater impact on human minds than those our low-wattage brains can find.

There is a huge presumption here which is that all humans share the same reward maximization function. In other words, that culture, upbringing, personal history, and random variation don't strongly affect it. I don't see much evidence that this is true.

It's more likely that, yes, there are sounds that have profoundly great effects on people, but each has their own. I would be very surprised if some AI trained on a global dataset could produce a set of sinusoids that tickled my neurons to anywhere near the same degree as the sound of my daughter's voice saying she loves me, or the song I heard when I was falling in love for the first time.

Remember, each of us is our own unique highly mutable neural net too.

Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by gjygj on Monday November 29, 2021 @08:11PM (#29387563)
There are songs with billions of views on YouTube.

We are not that unique, some sounds tickle us all.

Re:Music is a negative superstimulus for speech (2020) by munificent on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @12:56PM (#29395175)
Billions of Big Macs have been sold, but few would claim eating one as their all-time favorite meal.

Selecting the least bad option to the greatest number of people is not the same as finding the maximum value for any given person.