News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by bobthechef on Monday November 29, 2021 @01:53AM (#29377144)
I can't read the article, but the Spanish Inquisition is generally misunderstood in the historical context and innumerable myths have been spun about the affair through later Protestant leaflets and the like (outrageous claims of the genocide of millions, for example, compared to the actual 3,000-5,000 executed over the course of close to four centuries; compare this to the 150,000 secular witch burnings during the same period elsewhere in Europe). Most people don't even know what it was about, its historical character, or the historical antecedents that led to it in the end. Typically, it is used as a rhetorical device to halt discussion through whataboutism, like calling someone a racist without merit ("What about the SPANISH INQUISITION? You know, that horrible SPANISH INQUISITION? Oh, yes, the SPANISH INQUISITION was bad.").

How many people understand the converso crisis and its antecedents that threatened the very existence of Spain? The widespread social unrest that resulted that the Inquisition was brought in the resolve? Or that the judicial standards of the Inquisition were ahead of their time?

Persecution and forced conversion were not the objective, and indeed, the very notion of forced conversion is understood as not only evil by Catholics since it violates the conscience of the unbeliever, but it is an impossible feat because conversion can only be done freely. Rather, it was the widespread fear of feigned conversions, to obtain high offices, among the general populace that led to widespread unrest (many conversos had attained high ranking positions in the Spanish government). Whether there was any truth to these fears is another story, but the unrest was such a threat to the stability of Spain, that the Spanish Inquisition was called to resolve this crisis by subjecting the matter to an orderly judicial process. Some may argue that the later ultimatum of conversion or expulsion is a kind of de facto coerced conversion, but that's debatable, especially given the number of Jews who left for places like Poland.

We can criticize the affair (which, despite the investigation of claims of heresy, was actually of a secular character), but the attention it has received though the "Black Legend" as some egregious orgy of evil (committed by the Protestant's favorite punching bag, the Church) out of step with even the common practices of the day is simply wrong. Sadly, these sorts of things can seep into historical accounts and curricula, especially when they agree with prejudices. So I wonder about the substance of an article that uses this episode as a basis for investigating this question.

Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by alignItems on Monday November 29, 2021 @06:29AM (#29378583)
> How many people understand the converso crisis and its antecedents that threatened the very existence of Spain?

> Rather, it was the widespread fear of feigned conversions, to obtain high offices, among the general populace that led to widespread unrest (many conversos had attained high ranking positions in the Spanish government).

Sounds like the same tropes used to spread racism and fear of migrants in our times.

Except they set up an institution to investigate people from other races and cultures who tried to integrate and assimilate, tortured them for confessions and burned them alive if they were found to still secretly maintain any traditions of their own culture.

I can see why people with a Catholic identity would want to whitewash the history of their church, if they feel singled out for criticism. But you are right that it wasn’t only Catholics who did bad things, and the Inquisition probably didn’t do them _because_ they were Catholic. Doesn’t make it any less evil though.

Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by jsmith99 on Monday November 29, 2021 @03:38AM (#29377595)
Is 'widespread social unrest' an euphemism for the pogroms and riots such as the 1391 massacre of Spanish Jews, culminating in (a century later) all Jews being thrown out of Spain with little more than the shirts on their backs?
Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by happy_path on Monday November 29, 2021 @07:20AM (#29378970)
Sadly, anti-semitism was rampant in medieval Europe and I would say that it was present until XX century [1], and massacres of jews were popular among all countries, e.g.:

  - 1066 Granada Massacre (Granada was a Muslim Kingdom at that time)[2]
  - England: 1190 York Massacre [3]
  - Castile & Leon: 1391 Massacre [4]
  - Brussels: 1370 Brussels massacre [5]
  - ... [6]
In fact, I would say that jews have been the most hated ethno-religious group through Europe. The animosity of many cultures in Europe against them was almost omnipresent, both Christian and Islam-based.

Thus, jews were expelled from countries in Europe all the time [7], Spain was in fact one of the last countries to do so, on a side note, most countries expelled jews much earlier e.g.

Most of the Spanish jews chose to be baptized (among them the Abraham Senior, a senior member of the Castilian hacienda [8]) and is estimated that from a population of 400,000 a half of them remained in Iberia. Other sources (Henry Kamen) claim that [from] "80,000 Jews and 200,000 conversos, about 40,000 emigrated".

Of course, those who remained were subjected to discrimination as conversos, but that's another issue that even them was subjected to criticism by some important figures like Ignacio de Loyola (founder of Jesuits).

  [1] https://www.britannica.com/topic/anti-Semitism/Anti-Semitism-in-medieval-Europe
  [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1066_Granada_massacre
  [3] https://www.english-heritage.org.uk/visit/places/cliffords-tower-york/history-and-stories/massacre-of-the-jews/
  [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacre_of_1391
  [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brussels_massacre
  [6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Medieval_anti-Jewish_pogroms
  [7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expulsions_and_exoduses_of_Jews
  [8] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abraham_Senior
Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by jsmith99 on Monday November 29, 2021 @08:21AM (#29379552)
Oh yes, I'm not hating on Spain, but the parent comment seemed to deny the persecution Jews experienced and portrayed it as some sort of righteous anger on the part of good Catholics.
Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by happy_path on Monday November 29, 2021 @08:55AM (#29379888)
I don't think it was "rightous anger", but the hate against jews were commonplace in Medieval Ages. That also involves Spain of course. Until recently, most people were extremely racist/prejudiced against "the other" (hate against jews included).

However, I'm afraid that the popularization of the Spanish Inquisition [1] is due to propaganda. It is called Black Legend in academic circles and the publication in England and The Netherlands (and their orbits) of exagerated stories about the atrocities of the Spanish Crown, Spaniards and the Spanish Inquisition is because of that.

Most of the sufferers of the Spanish Inquisiton were Spaniards, and the Holy Office had the aim of control (with an iron fist) the population, not exterminate them. In fact, during its 4 centuries of life, the Inquisition executed around 6,000 people [2] (according to Henry Kamen). For example, you can compare to the 57,000 - 70,000 people killed during the reign of Henry VIII (only 40 years)[3][4]

  - [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Legend_(Spain)
  - [2] https://strangenotions.com/spanish-inquisition/
  - [3] https://www.history.co.uk/article/the-killer-king-how-many-people-did-henry-viii-execute
  - [4] https://www.bbc.co.uk/teach/how-could-you-survive-in-tudor-england/znvmkmn
Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by AnimalMuppet on Monday November 29, 2021 @11:28AM (#29381723)
Control with an iron fist is better than extermination, but it's a pretty low bar...
Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by happy_path on Monday November 29, 2021 @11:35AM (#29381821)
We are talking about XV-XIX centuries. Most countries had different levels of "iron fist" population control for a segment of their population. It could be control of women, poor people, people of different ethnicity, jews, etc.

What I want to highlight, is that the behavior of the Spanish Inquisition, while abhorrent to our XXI eyes, were not uncommon during those times. Note please that I'm not justifying anything, I'm making a point that Human History has been horrible during almost of its existence: discrimination, wars, slavery, segregation, etc. Human Rights are a "new thing".

Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by elnatro on Monday November 29, 2021 @06:13AM (#29378481)
Spain was the las country to expel Jews in Europe indeed.
Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by GlennS on Monday November 29, 2021 @04:59AM (#29378047)
"Secular witch burnings" is a term I haven't heard before.

Religiously motivated, but conducted by laypeople, yes?

Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by trasz on Monday November 29, 2021 @04:24AM (#29377835)
> the very notion of forced conversion is understood as not only evil by Catholics

Funny you say that, given how one of the cornerstones of Catholicism is forced conversion of children.

Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by szeptik on Monday November 29, 2021 @04:58AM (#29378036)
As I understand it, conversion requires renouncing your previous faith. If you are referring to the practice of baptizing newborn babies, I don't think it can considered a conversion (much less a forced one) at all.
Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by trasz on Monday November 29, 2021 @09:52AM (#29380505)
Not really: “Religious conversion is the adoption of a set of beliefs identified with one particular religious denomination to the exclusion of others.” It would seem rather pointless to have a separate terms for “conversion” and “conversion from effectively atheism”.

And it’s definitely a forced conversion: the whole purpose is to explicitly ignore one’s will, and is used to “trap” children into religion, generally followed by indoctrination about alleged “obligations” and “duties”.

Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by tsol on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @11:52AM (#29405924)
In the case all schools are conversion factories and all children are converted, religious or secular(as far as I know no children are born believing in rational empiricism). Words have set meanings for a reason.

Even so is it isn't forceful-- you'll find children in fact want to be like their parents, and even go out of their way to imitate their behavior and beliefs.

Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by trasz on Thursday December 02, 2021 @11:50AM (#29418644)
Religious conversion is by definition a conversion to a religion. In civilised countries schools don't spread religion. Teaching basic rationality and logic isn't conversion.

Catholic child conversion is forceful in that it ignores the will of the subject. You'll find that even though children tend to follow their parents, many/most of children of Catholic parents don't want to have anything to do with that religion once they grow up. You'll also find that the chance of someone becoming a Catholic is close to zero unless they have been indoctrinated from very early age. You'll find a lot of statistics showing both.

Re:Long-run effects of religious persecution: evidence from ... by tsol on Thursday December 02, 2021 @08:05PM (#29425359)
>Teaching basic rationality and logic isn't conversion.

Except you are defining what logic is, while many would disagree so it's still enforcing your own world view on others. The only difference is instead of enforcing a creator, it enforces lack of a creator.

>Catholic child conversion is forceful in that it ignores the will of the subject.

I was talking about religion, and now you're talking about the sect of one religion. Are jainists subject to this problem? Buddhists? Is shinto? Your making big sweeping statements and giving granular defenses.

>You'll find that even though children tend to follow their parents, many/most of children of Catholic parents don't want to have anything to do with that religion once they grow up. You'll also find that the chance of someone becoming a Catholic is close to zero unless they have been indoctrinated from very early age

[Citation needed]. Your adding a lot of qualifiers, sure there are statistics that reflect a fraction of what you're saying but you're creating a huge narrative around it that's unfounded.

>Religious conversion is by definition a conversion to a religion

Okay and conversion just means "a change in character, form or function". Sounds like exactly what school is designed to do. What difference religion makes is up for debate-- brainwashing political or social values is just as dangerous for example but you took no issue with that.