Re:Speech Recognition Leaps Forward
by _delirium on Monday August 29, 2011 @11:41AM
(#2937524)
Refutations of Chomsky haven't really refuted a more general built-in-functionality argument, looked at on a wider plane than sentence parsing. Not many people in neuroscience seriously reject the idea in the bigger picture, e.g. the idea that there are parts of the brain hard-wired for vision processing, and that we seem to have evolved to be more adept at certain kinds of vision-processing tasks than others. It's even widely believed (though more controversially) that we have built-in face-recognition machinery, which operates differently from the general object-recognition machinery. Similarly, we seem to have wiring fairly specialized for tasks like "maintain balance" and "process vibrations in the ear".
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Speech Recognition Leaps Forward
by bluekeybox on Monday August 29, 2011 @11:54AM
(#2937565)
> Nobody in neuroscience seriously rejects some variety of built-in functionality in the bigger picture
Absolutely correct, but I was using the more narrow interpretation of "human intelligence" as "traits that make us distinct from most other mammals". Most higher animals have specialized structures for vision processing and most of them are also good at "maintaining balance". What makes humans unique is the adaptability of our brains I was talking about and the ability to acquire different symbolic systems with relative ease (at least as young children).